序贯平行对照设计用于评估二分类终点的诱导、维持、长期及其他治疗效果
针对慢性病需同时评估诱导与维持效应,本文提出将两阶段序贯平行对照设计(SPCD)用于二分类终点,可视为三种常用设计的混合并具额外优势。采用加权组合检验并纳入成分间相关性以利用两阶段全部数据,用多重插补处理非随机缺失,通过模拟和实例说明方法应用。
要点
- 两阶段SPCD可用于二分类终点的诱导、维持、长期及其他治疗效果评估。
- SPCD可视为三种常用设计的混合,与再随机撤药维持设计相比无需再随机化。
- 采用加权组合检验并纳入成分间相关性,以利用两阶段全部数据评估总体疗效。
核心结论
- 两阶段SPCD可用于二分类终点的诱导、维持、长期及其他治疗效果评估,可视为三种常用设计的混合并具有额外优势。
研究设计与样本
- 本文使用两阶段序贯平行对照设计(SPCD)进行二分类终点的临床试验,用于诱导、维持、长期及其他治疗效果评估。
主要发现
- 与再随机撤药维持设计相比,SPCD无需再随机化以简化试验操作,并为正式长期疗效和安全性分析提供对照数据。
- 采用加权组合检验并纳入成分间相关性,以利用两阶段全部可用数据进行总体治疗效果评估。
- 应用多重插补方法处理非随机缺失数据。
- 通过模拟评估方法性能,并使用数据示例说明方法应用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
For a chronic disease, besides the treatment induction effect, it is also important to demonstrate the maintenance effect of long-term treatment use. To fulfill these and other objectives for a clinical study, we often apply one of three designs: the active treatment lead-in followed by randomized maintenance design, the randomized induction followed by re-randomized withdrawal maintenance design and the treat-through design (FDA 2022). Separately, a two-stage sequential parallel comparison design (SPCD) is frequently used in therapeutic areas where placebo has a large effect. In this paper, we use a SPCD for a clinical trial with a binary endpoint for induction, maintenance, long-term and other treatment effect assessments. This SPCD can actually be treated as a hybrid of the above three designs and has some additional advantages. For example, compared to the re-randomized withdrawal maintenance design, the SPCD does not need a re-randomization to simplify trial operation and it also provides controlled data for formal long-term efficacy and safety analyses. To fully utilize all available data of the two stages for an overall treatment effect evaluation, a weighted combination test is considered with the incorporation of correlations of the components. Further, a multiple imputation approach is applied to handle missing not at random data. Simulations are conducted to evaluate the performances of the methods and a data example is employed to illustrate the applications of the methods.
引用
- Quan H, Xu Z, Chen X, et al. Sequential Parallel Comparison Design for Assessing Induction, Maintenance, Long-Term, and Other Treatment Effects on a Binary Endpoint. Stat Med. 2026. PMID: 41569397. doi:10.1002/sim.70382
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。