检测研究排除中的种族和民族差异:一项针对失眠孕妇的随机对照试验的筛选结果
本研究比较了4235名来自七个种族/民族组的参与者在一项测试两种数字睡眠干预以预防围产期抑郁的随机对照试验中的纳入与排除比例。八项2×7卡方检验显示,所有八项资格标准下的排除比例均因种族/民族而异;逻辑回归显示,与白人参与者相比,黑人参与者在八项标准中的三项上被排除的比值比显著更高(比值比范围为1.70至6.86)。结论认为,资格标准以因种族/民族而异的比例排除了 prospective 研究参与者,这种排除差异可能导致少数族裔孕妇在行为健康随机对照试验中的入组不足。
要点
- 所有八项资格标准的排除比例均因种族/民族而异。
- 黑人参与者因睡眠呼吸暂停等共病被排除的可能性更高(X2(6, N=4151)=20.94,p=.002)。
- 亚洲参与者因报告亚临床失眠症状被排除的可能性更高(X2(6, N=4151)=85.99,p<.001)。
核心结论
- 资格标准以因种族/民族而异的比例排除了 prospective 研究参与者。
- 试验排除的差异可能导致少数族裔孕妇在行为健康随机对照试验中的入组不足。
- 量化并报告资格差异使研究者能够更精确地评估特定纳入标准与研究结果对多样化人群的普遍性之间的权衡。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究比较了来自七个种族/民族组的参与者(n=4235)在一项测试两种数字睡眠干预以预防围产期抑郁的随机对照试验中的纳入与排除比例。
- 进行了八项2×7卡方检验,以比较每个种族/民族组因每项资格标准被排除的比例。
- 拟合逻辑回归以估计种族/民族组与基于每项资格标准的排除之间关系的 magnitude。
主要发现
- 所有八项资格标准的排除参与者比例均因种族/民族而异。
- 黑人参与者因睡眠呼吸暂停等共病被排除的可能性更高(X2(6, N=4151)=20.94,p=.002)。
- 亚洲参与者因报告亚临床失眠症状被排除的可能性更高(X2(6, N=4151)=85.99,p<.001)。
- 与白人参与者相比,黑人参与者在八项资格标准中的三项上被排除的比值比显著更高(比值比范围为1.70至6.86)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Eligibility criteria are a critical component of a well-designed clinical trial, enhancing trial safety and internal validity. Yet, data suggest that exclusion rates based on these criteria often vary by participant race/ethnicity. METHOD: This study compared the proportion of participants (n = 4235) from seven racial/ethnic groups, who were included versus excluded from participation in a randomized controlled trial (RCT) testing two digital sleep interventions for the prevention of perinatal depression. Eight 2 × 7 chi-squared tests were conducted to compare the proportion of each racial/ethnic group excluded due to each eligibility criterion. Logistic regressions were fitted to estimate the magnitude of the relationship between racial/ethnic group and exclusion based on each eligibility criterion. RESULTS: The proportion of excluded participants differed by race/ethnicity across all eight eligibility criteria. For example, Black participants were more likely to be excluded due to comorbid conditions such as sleep apnea X2 (6, N = 4151) = 20.94, p = .002, and Asian participants were more likely to be excluded for reporting subclinical insomnia symptoms X2 (6, N = 4151) = 85.99, p < .001. Logistic regressions showed that compared to White participants, Black participants had significantly higher odds (odds ratios ranging from 1.70 to 6.86) of study exclusion for three of the eight eligibility criteria. CONCLUSIONS: Eligibility criteria excluded prospective study participants at different rates dependent on their race/ethnicity. Differences in trial exclusion can contribute to the under-enrollment of minoritized pregnant people in RCTs for behavioral health. Quantifying and reporting eligibility disparities enables investigators to more precisely evaluate the trade-offs of specific inclusion criteria against the generalizability of findings to diverse populations.
引用
- Ponting C, Sorensen C, McClelland B, et al. Detecting racial and ethnic disparities in study exclusion: screening outcomes from a RCT for pregnant women with insomnia. Trials. 2026. PMID: 41530879. doi:10.1186/s13063-026-09422-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。