集群随机对照试验中纵向与生存结局的贝叶斯多层联合模型
研究提出贝叶斯多层联合模型(MJM),用于集群随机对照试验(CRCT)中同时评估干预对相关纵向与生存结局的效应。应用于评估PAX良好行为游戏的CRCT数据(2011-2012学年313个班级4189名一年级学生),显示PAX显著改善心理健康轨迹并降低精神障碍诊断风险。模拟研究表明MJM估计更准确,忽略层次结构会导致有偏推断并低估干预效应。
要点
- MJM可同时评估CRCT中干预对纵向与生存结局的效应,并考虑聚类结构。
- PAX项目显著改善心理健康轨迹并降低精神障碍诊断风险。
- 忽略层次结构会导致有偏推断并低估干预效应。
核心结论
- 所提出的MJM为分析CRCT数据提供了稳健灵活的分析框架,强调评估群体水平干预时考虑聚类的重要性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究提出多层联合模型(MJM),并应用于一项评估PAX良好行为游戏的大型CRCT经验数据,该试验涉及2011-2012学年313个班级的4189名一年级学生。
- 通过模拟研究在不同条件下评估MJM性能,包括删失率、集群大小、组水平方差和生存模型设定。
主要发现
- PAX项目显著改善心理健康轨迹并降低精神障碍诊断风险。
- MJM优于传统联合模型,产生更准确的估计和标准误。
- 经验和模拟研究结果均表明,忽略层次结构会导致有偏推断并低估干预效应。
关键数值与推荐
- 心理健康在三个时间点评估:PAX前(2012年1月)、PAX后(2012年6月)和五年级(2016年6月)。
- 首次精神障碍诊断时间追踪至2024年3月。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Cluster randomized controlled trials (CRCTs) are commonly used when interventions are delivered at the group level. Since data from CTCTs are inherently multilevel, methods that properly account for clustering are required. Joint modeling (JM) of longitudinal and survival data allows for simultaneous evaluation of intervention effects on repeated measures and time-to-event outcomes, offering a comprehensive view of intervention effects. However, existing JMs do not accommodate clustered data structures typically of CRCTs. This study introduces a multilevel joint model (MJM) to simultaneously evaluate intervention effects on correlated longitudinal and survival outcomes. The model was applied to empirical data from a large CRCT evaluating the PAX Good Behavior Game, a classroom-based mental health intervention involving 4189 Grade 1 students across 313 classrooms during the 2011-2012 school year. Mental health was assessed at three time points: pre-PAX (January 2012), post-PAX (June 2012), and Grade 5 (June 2016). Time-to-first mental disorder diagnosis was tracked through March 2024. Simulation studies further evaluated the MJM's performance under varying conditions, including censoring rates, cluster sizes, group-level variances, and survival model specifications. Results indicated the PAX program significantly improved mental health trajectories and reduced the risk of mental disorder diagnoses. The MJM outperformed traditional JMs by producing more accurate estimates and standard errors. Both empirical and simulation findings demonstrated that ignoring hierarchical structures leads to biased inferences and underestimation of intervention effects. The proposed MJM offers a robust and flexible analytic framework for analyzing data from CRCTs, emphasizing the importance of accounting for clustering in evaluating group-based interventions.
引用
- Liu Y, Jiang D, Torabi M, et al. A Bayesian Multilevel Joint Modeling of Longitudinal and Survival Outcomes in Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial Studies. Stat Med. 2026. PMID: 41567118. doi:10.1002/sim.70385
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。