石膏固定与手术治疗不稳定外踝骨折(SUPER-FIN):随机非劣效性临床试验
该随机非劣效性试验在芬兰一家大学医院创伤中心纳入126例静态X线显示Weber B型腓骨骨折、踝穴一致但外旋应力试验判定不稳定的骨骼成熟患者,比较石膏固定6周与切开复位内固定加石膏固定6周。主要终点为2年时Olerud-Molander踝关节评分(OMAS),非劣效界值-8分。结果显示石膏固定组平均OMAS为89分,手术组为87分,组间平均差异1.3分(95%CI -4.8至7.3),石膏固定不劣于手术,且治疗相关伤害更少。
要点
- 对静态X线踝穴一致但外旋应力试验不稳定的Weber B型外踝骨折,石膏固定2年OMAS不劣于手术。
- 石膏固定组平均OMAS 89分,手术组87分,组间平均差异1.3分(95%CI -4.8至7.3),在预设非劣效界值-8分内。
- 石膏固定组治疗相关伤害少于手术组,手术组有9例因内固定物取出接受手术。
核心结论
- 对初次X线踝穴一致但外旋应力试验判定不稳定的单踝Weber B型踝骨折,石膏固定不劣于手术治疗。
- 总体而言,与手术相比,石膏固定发生的治疗相关伤害更少。
研究设计与样本
- 随机、实用性、非劣效性临床试验,在芬兰一家大学医院创伤中心进行,时间为2013年1月16日至2021年7月7日。
- 纳入840例骨骼成熟(年龄≥16岁)的孤立性Weber B型腓骨骨折患者,经透视下标准外旋应力试验评估骨折不稳定性。
- 排除714例(569例为稳定骨折、踝穴不一致或骨折脱位),其余126例踝穴一致但不稳定的患者被随机分组。
- 干预组分别接受常规石膏固定6周(n=62)或切开复位内固定加石膏固定6周(n=64)。
- 主要非劣效性终点为2年时Olerud-Molander踝关节评分(OMAS,范围0-100分,评分越高表示结局越好、症状越少),预设非劣效界值为-8分。
主要发现
- 126例随机参与者中121例(96%)完成研究;在完成2年随访的121例意向性治疗分析中,石膏固定组平均OMAS为89分,手术组为87分,组间平均差异1.3分(95%CI -4.8至7.3)。
- 任何次要结局均未观察到统计学显著的组间差异。
- 每组各有1例参与者有影像学骨不连证据。
- 手术组中,1例发生浅表伤口感染,1例伤口愈合延迟,9例接受内固定物取出手术,其中2例发生术后感染(1例深部、1例浅表)。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要终点非劣效界值预设为-8分(OMAS)。
- 2年OMAS组间平均差异1.3分(95%CI -4.8至7.3),置信区间下限高于-8分界值。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论认为,对初次X线踝穴一致但外旋应力试验判定不稳定的单踝Weber B型踝骨折,石膏固定不劣于手术,且治疗相关伤害更少。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare cast immobilisation with surgery using open reduction and internal plate fixation for unimalleolar Weber B ankle fractures with a congruent mortise on initial radiography but deemed unstable by external rotation stress testing. DESIGN: Randomised, pragmatic, non-inferiority, clinical trial. SETTING: One specialist university hospital trauma centre in Finland, 16 January 2013 to 7 July 2021. PARTICIPANTS: 840 skeletally mature patients (age ≥16 years) with an isolated Weber B fibula fracture on static radiographs. Fracture instability was assessed by standard external rotation stress test under fluoroscopy. 714 participants were excluded (569 with stable fracture, mortise incongruency, or fracture dislocation) and the remaining 126 patients with a congruent but unstable ankle mortise were randomised. INTERVENTIONS: Participants were randomly allocated to receive either conventional cast immobilisation for six weeks (n=62) or surgical treatment with open reduction and internal plate fixation followed by cast immobilisation for six weeks (n=64). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The primary, non-inferiority outcome was the Olerud-Molander Ankle Score (OMAS; range 0-100 points; higher scores indicating better outcomes and fewer symptoms) at two years. The predefined non-inferiority margin for the primary outcome was set at -8 points. Secondary outcomes were ankle function, pain, health related quality of life, ankle range of motion, and radiographic outcome. Treatment related adverse events were also recorded. RESULTS: 121 out of 126 randomised participants (96%) completed the study. In the primary intention-to-treat analysis of 121 participants completing two year follow-up, the mean OMAS was 89 in the cast immobilisation group and 87 in the surgery group (between group mean difference 1.3 points, 95% confidence interval -4.8 to 7.3). No statistically significant between group differences were observed in any secondary outcomes. One participant in each group had radiographic evidence of non-union. In the surgery group, one participant had a superficial wound infection, one had delayed wound healing, and nine underwent procedures to remove hardware, two of whom developed postoperative infections (one deep and one superficial). CONCLUSIONS: Cast immobilisation proved non-inferior to surgery for the treatment of unimalleolar Weber B ankle fractures with a congruent mortise on initial radiography but deemed unstable by external rotation stress testing. Overall, fewer treatment related harms occurred with cast immobilisation compared with surgery. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01758796.
引用
- Kortekangas T, Lehtola R, Leskelä HV, et al. Cast immobilisation versus surgery for unstable lateral malleolus fractures (SUPER-FIN): randomised non-inferiority clinical trial. BMJ. 2026. PMID: 41534905. doi:10.1136/bmj-2025-085295
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。