界定种族健康公平:术语与概念化的整合性分析
本研究采用整合性综述框架,分析RWJF-Cochrane项目中157篇系统综述、29份访谈和16篇文章里种族健康公平的定义。结果从理论文献(n=16)和利益相关者转录(n=16)中获得32个定义,系统综述均未包含定义。作者基于共同主题提出一个工作定义,强调健康公平正义、结局与可及性平等及种族社会后果的影响。
要点
- 系统综述中均未发现种族健康公平的定义。
- 从理论文献和利益相关者转录中各获16个定义,共32个。
- 定义对改善医疗可及性在实现种族健康公平中的作用存在差异。
核心结论
- 作者认为,清晰一致的种族健康公平定义将帮助研究者、实践者和政策制定者制定减少种族健康不平等的指标和干预措施。
- 作者提出种族健康公平的工作定义,强调健康中的公平与正义、跨种族化群体的健康结局与可及性平等,以及承认种族和/或族裔的社会后果可能影响健康或所接受医疗照护的质量。
- 作者指出, understandings 存在变异性领域,需要进一步讨论。
研究设计与样本
- 采用整合性综述框架,分析RWJF-Cochrane项目已发表研究中种族健康公平术语的当前定义。
- 通过双人筛选所有识别的研究和访谈转录来识别定义,包括2020年以来发表的近期系统综述、理论和概念健康文献,以及与参与解决健康公平的系统综述利益相关者的倾听练习。
- 使用Braun和Clarke框架通过主题编码分析识别的定义。
- 审查了157篇系统综述、29份访谈和16篇与种族健康公平相关的文章。
主要发现
- 从理论和概念健康文献(n=16)和利益相关者转录(n=16)中获得32个种族健康公平定义。
- 没有系统综述包含种族健康公平的定义。
- 检索到的定义强调健康或医疗照护中的平等,包括结局、过程或照护;医疗照护环境中的歧视主题;以及承认健康社会决定因素与健康公平的交叉。
- 定义在改善医疗照护可及性对实现种族健康公平的作用上存在差异。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 作者指出, understandings 存在变异性领域,需要进一步讨论。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The current literature lacks an established and adoptable definition of "racial health equity." This study aimed to catalog and evaluate, via thematic analyses, definitions and terminology related to racial health equity across the specific studies from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and Cochrane-US (United States) (RWJF-Cochrane) "Centering Racial Health Equity in Systematic Reviews" project and to propose a working definition based on study findings. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We employed an integrative review framework to analyze current definitions of racial health equity terms identified within published studies from the RWJF-Cochrane project. Definitions of racial health equity were identified via dual reviewer screening of all identified studies and interview transcripts, which included recent systematic reviews (published since 2020), theoretical and conceptual health literature, and listening exercises with interest holders involved in systematic reviews addressing health equity. Identified definitions were analyzed via thematic coding using the Braun and Clarke framework. RESULTS: We reviewed 157 systematic reviews, 29 interviews, and 16 articles related to racial health equity for the presence of racial health equity definitions. This review resulted in 32 definitions of racial health equity from theoretical and conceptual health literature (n = 16) and interest holder transcripts (n = 16). No systematic reviews contained definitions of racial health equity. Retrieved definitions emphasize equality in health or health care, including outcomes, processes, or care; themes of discrimination in health-care settings; and acknowledgments of the intersections of social determinants of health with health equity. Definitions varied on the role of improving health-care access in achieving racial health equity. A working definition of racial health equity is proposed using common themes identified across definitions. CONCLUSION: Our findings highlight that a clear and consistent definition of racial health equity will assist researchers, practitioners, and policymakers with developing metrics and interventions aimed at reducing racial health inequities. Thus, we propose a working definition for racial health equity, which emphasizes 1) fairness and justice in health, 2) equality in health outcomes and access across racialized groups, 3) a recognition that social consequences of one's race and/or ethnicity may influence health or the quality of health care received. We also note areas of variability in understandings that require further discussion.
引用
- Terhune EA, Dagne MB, Barsoum M, et al. Defining racial health equity: an integrative analysis of terminology and conceptualizations. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 41391733. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.112103
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。