准实验研究的系统综述:挑战与考量
本文描述纳入准实验研究(如双重差分、中断时间序列、回归断点、工具变量、合成控制)的系统综述面临的关键方法学挑战与考量,并给出对综述作者和研究界的建议,强调检索范围、团队专业构成、偏倚风险评估的细致性及估计目标差异的解释。
要点
- 推荐检索广泛文献数据库与灰色文献(含预印本库),不依赖研究设计特定词检索。
- 综述团队应包含多名准实验设计专家,双人独立筛选与偏倚风险评估。
- 建议使用细致偏倚风险评估工具(如改良ROBINS-I),并考虑不同设计估计目标的差异。
核心结论
- 对纳入准实验研究的系统综述作者提出5条推荐:广泛检索含预印本库的数据库与灰色文献;不依赖研究设计特定词检索;团队含多名准实验设计专家并双人筛选与偏倚评估;使用足够细致的偏倚风险评估方法(如改良ROBINS-I);解释不同设计估计值时考虑估计目标差异。
- 研究者可考虑为可行性将系统综述纳入范围限制为准实验研究,但更包容的方法更可取,因为多种方法学设计的良好研究可能比违反因果假设的准实验更可信。
- 研究界应提高命名一致性、作者描述研究设计的透明度,并考虑为准实验研究制定报告标准与方案注册以改善系统综述中的研究识别。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为方法学论述,描述纳入准实验研究的系统综述的关键方法学挑战与考量,关注当前推荐及既往综述中应用的方法。
关键数值与推荐
- 推荐(1):检索广泛文献数据库与灰色文献,包括预印本库。
- 推荐(2):不要求研究设计特定词用于识别,因准实验研究命名不一致且数据库标引差。
- 推荐(3):综述团队应包括多名准实验设计专家,双人独立筛选与偏倚风险评估。
- 推荐(4):使用足够细致的偏倚风险评估方法以识别最可能报告无偏因果效应估计的研究(如改良ROBINS-I)。
- 推荐(5):解释不同准实验设计的估计值时考虑不同估计目标的影响。
临床怎么用
- 作者推荐系统综述作者按上述5条推荐实施;研究者可考虑为可行性限制纳入准实验研究,但更包容的方法更可取;研究界应提高命名一致性与报告透明度,并考虑制定报告标准与方案注册。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In contrast to other observational study designs, quasi-experimental approaches (eg, difference-in-differences, interrupted time series, regression discontinuity, instrumental variable, synthetic control) account for some sources of unmeasured confounding and can estimate causal effects under weaker assumptions. Studies which apply quasi-experimental approaches have increased in popularity in recent decades, therefore investigators conducting systematic reviews of observational studies, particularly in biomedical, public health, or epidemiologic content areas, must be prepared to encounter and appropriately assess these approaches. OBJECTIVE: Our objective is to describe key methodological challenges and considerations for systematic reviews including quasi-experimental studies, with attention to current recommendations and approaches which have been applied in previous reviews. CONCLUSION: Recommendations for authors of systematic reviews: We recommend that individuals conducting systematic reviews including quasi-experimental studies: (1) search a broad range of bibliographic databases and gray literature, including preprint repositories; (2) do not use search strategies which require specific terms for study design for identification, given inconsistent nomenclature and poor database indexing for quasi-experimental studies; (3) ensure that their review team includes several individuals with expertise in quasi-experimental designs for screening and risk of bias assessment in duplicate; (4) use an approach to risk of bias assessment which is sufficiently granular to identify studies most likely to report unbiased estimates of causal effects (eg, modified Risk Of Bias In Nonrandomized Studies - of Interventions); and (5) consider the implications of varied estimands when interpreting estimates from different quasi-experimental designs. Researchers may also consider restricting systematic review inclusion to quasi-experimental studies for feasibility when addressing research questions with large bodies of literature. However, a more inclusive approach is preferred, as well-designed studies using a variety of methodological approaches may be more credible than a quasi-experiment which violates causal assumptions. Recommendations for the research community: Many of the challenges faced in conducting systematic reviews of quasi-experimental studies would be ameliorated by improved consistency in nomenclature, as well as greater transparency from authors in describing their research designs. The broader community (eg, research networks, journals) should consider the creation and implementation of reporting standards and protocol registration for quasi-experimental studies to improve study identification in systematic reviews.
引用
- Windle SB, Harper S, Arneja J, et al. Systematic reviews of quasi-experimental studies: challenges and considerations. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 41461359. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.112121
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。