文献速递流行病学与生物统计医学教育与科研方法

引用率预测因素与引用偏倚问题:范围综述

Predictors of citation rates and the problem of citation bias: a scoping review.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2025-11-19

该范围综述检索四个电子数据库并筛查纳入文献的参考文献列表,纳入165项报告引用率预测因素或引用偏倚的实证元研究,共评估54个不同因素、786项定量分析。其中79项研究(48%)明确建议修改论文特征以提高引用率,而非优先考虑科学贡献,作者认为这类建议可能与科学诚信原则相冲突。

要点

  • 共纳入165项研究,评估54个引用率预测因素,涉及786项定量分析。
  • 78项研究(48%)考察引用偏倚,79项研究(48%)旨在优化论文特征以提高作者自身引用率。
  • 79项研究(48%)明确建议修改标题长度或作者数量等论文特征以提高引用率,而非优先考虑科学贡献。

核心结论

  • 165项纳入研究中79项(48%)明确建议修改论文特征(如标题长度或作者数量)以提高引用率,而非优先考虑科学贡献,这类建议可能与强调相关性与方法学严谨性优于策略性引用实践的科学诚信原则相冲突。
  • 鉴于识别出引用率显著增加的分析比例很高,不能排除发表偏倚。

研究设计与样本

  • 范围综述,按PRISMA-ScR清单报告,检索四个电子数据库并筛查所有纳入文献的参考文献列表。
  • 纳入卫生保健领域报告引用率预测因素和/或引用偏倚来源的实证元研究,共纳入165项研究,数据以频数、构成比和百分比等描述性统计呈现。

主要发现

  • 共评估54个不同的引用率预测因素,涉及786项定量分析。
  • 78项研究(48%)旨在考察引用偏倚,79项研究(48%)旨在优化论文特征以提高作者自身引用率,其余7项研究(4%)分析发表层面的基础设施特征以使所有研究更易获取。

关键数值与推荐

  • 165项纳入研究中79项(48%)明确建议修改论文特征(如标题长度或作者数量)以提高引用率,而非优先考虑科学贡献。

局限性

  • 鉴于识别出引用率显著增加的分析比例很高,不能排除发表偏倚。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To systematically map the factors associated with citation rates, to categorize the types of studies evaluating these factors, and to obtain an overall status of citation bias in scientific health literature. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A scoping review was reported following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses scoping review extension checklist. Four electronic databases were searched, and the reference-lists of all included articles were screened. Empirical meta-research studies reporting any source of predictors of citation rates and/or citation bias within health care were included. Data are presented by descriptive statistics such as frequencies, portions, and percentages. RESULTS: A total of 165 studies were included. Fifty-four distinct factors of citation rates were evaluated in 786 quantitative analyses. Regardless of using the same basic methodological approach to calculate citation rate, 78 studies (48%) aimed to examined citation bias, whereas 79 studies (48%) aimed to optimizing article characteristics to enhance authors' own citation rates. The remaining seven studies (4%) analyzed infrastructural characteristics at publication level to make all studies more accessible. CONCLUSION: Seventy-nine of the 165 included studies (48%) explicitly recommended modifying paper characteristics-such as title length or author count-to boost citations rather than prioritizing scientific contribution. Such recommendations may conflict with principles of scientific integrity, which emphasize relevance and methodological rigor over strategic citation practices. Given the high proportion of analyses identifying a significant increase in citation rates, publication bias cannot be ruled out. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Why was the study done? Within scientific research, it is important to cite previous research. This is done for specific reasons, including crediting earlier authors and providing a credible and trustworthy background for conducting the study. However, findings suggest that citations are not always chosen for their intended purpose. This is known as citation bias. What did the researchers do? The researchers searched for all existing studies evaluating predictors of citation rate, ie, how often is a specific study referred to by other researchers. They systematically mapped these studies to find out both the level of citation bias and the types of citation bias present in scientific health literature. To find these studies, the researchers searched four electronic databases and screened the reference lists of all included studies to be sure to include as many studies as possible. What did the researchers find? The researchers found a total of 165 studies that evaluated predictors of citation rate in no less than 786 analyses. However, the researchers found that the studies differed in the way they evaluated predictors of citation rate, as 78 studies (48%) evaluated citation bias, meaning if researchers referred to earlier studies in a nonscientific way, whereas 79 studies (48%) evaluated predictors of citation rate to identify ways to increase authors' own citation rates. The remaining seven studies (4%) wanted to find characteristics that could make the studies more accessible. What do the findings mean? The study identified a very large number of predictors of citation rate being evaluated and even indicating risk of citation bias. Furthermore, the study found that 48% of the papers recommended changing things like title length or number of authors to get more citations, instead of focusing on the actual scientific contribution. These recommendations might, however, be in conflict with scientific principles and honesty.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nørgaard B, Lie KE, Lund H, et al. Predictors of citation rates and the problem of citation bias: a scoping review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 41265666. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.112057

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。