失纳:命名与定义健康研究中边缘化人群的不公平缺席
本文提出「失纳(dysinclusion)」这一概念,用以命名和定义边缘化人群在健康研究中不公平的缺席或不可见。作者通过实例界定失纳并将其与邻近流行病学概念区分,提出数据覆盖、不参与和不可见三种失纳过程,论证失纳应作为方法学严谨性的核心标准加以识别和管理。
要点
- 失纳指本应纳入研究的人群不公平地缺席或不可见,是公平与方法交叉的独立概念。
- 失纳通过数据覆盖、不参与和不可见三种过程发生,并嵌入研究方法之中。
- 作者认为失纳不仅应被视为偏倚来源,还应作为方法学严谨性的核心标准加以管理。
核心结论
- 命名失纳挑战健康研究中对排斥和不公平的常态化,为连接公平伦理与研究 Methods 提供语言。
- 使失纳可见,可将模式化缺席重新定义为对公平和科学严谨性的双重威胁,需要 deliberate 认识、问责和改变。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为概念性论文,通过实例界定失纳并描述其机制,将其与邻近流行病学概念区分,并提出三种失纳过程类型。
主要发现
- 失纳揭示结构性边缘化如何嵌入研究方法:边缘化群体缺席于数据来源、因研究设计或参与障碍被排除,或因测量和报告实践而不可见。
- 这些模式化缺席损害研究的有效性、相关性和伦理基础。
- 作者提出三种失纳过程:数据覆盖、不参与和不可见。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为失纳不仅应作为偏倚或有效性威胁的来源加以识别和管理,还应作为健康研究设计与实施中方法学严谨性的核心标准。
- 作者认为应像评估研究的偏倚或混杂一样评估失纳,并通过更好的研究设计、更包容的数据收集和更清晰的报告来减少失纳。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Marginalized populations are frequently absent or invisible in health research. Yet this problem is seldom characterized as a distinct methodological concern. Existing concepts like selection bias or generalizability approach these inequities primarily as technical limitations, not as methodological deficiencies. We introduce dysinclusion to name and define the inequitable absence or invisibility of groups who should be included in research. Our objective is to establish dysinclusion as a distinct concept at the intersection of equity and methods, distinguish it from existing methodological concepts, and examine how it functions, why it matters, and how it can be addressed. METHODS: We draw on examples to define dysinclusion and describe its mechanisms. We differentiate dysinclusion from adjacent epidemiological concepts, and propose three types of dysinclusion processes: data coverage, nonparticipation, and invisibility. RESULTS: Dysinclusion reveals how structural marginalization becomes embedded in research methods. It occurs when marginalized groups are absent from data sources, excluded through study design or barriers to participation, or rendered invisible by measurement and reporting practices. These patterned absences compromise the validity, relevance, and ethical foundation of research. We argue that dysinclusion should be identified and managed not only as a source of bias or threat to validity, but as a central criterion of methodological rigor in the design and implementation of health research. CONCLUSION: Naming dysinclusion challenges the normalization of exclusion and inequity in health research. Dysinclusion offers language to link the ethical concept of equity with research methods. Making dysinclusion visible reframes patterned absence as a threat to both equity and scientific rigor-one that demands deliberate recognition, accountability, and change. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Some groups-like people with disabilities, racialized communities, or those living in poverty-are often missing from health research. Even when they face some of the greatest health challenges, these groups are frequently left out of studies, underrepresented in data, or not even recognized as distinct populations. This absence has serious consequences: it limits what we know about their health, weakens the accuracy of research findings, and can make existing health disparities worse. This problem is common, but there is no widely used method or term in health research to describe or address it. Researchers typically think about who is missing from studies in terms of technical issues like bias or generalizability. These concepts do not fully capture the deeper problem of structural inequality, and make it seem as though ethical concerns, like health equity, are separate from the methods that lead to rigorous science. This paper introduces a new term: dysinclusion. Dysinclusion means the unfair or unjust absence of groups that should be part of health research. It's not just about who is missing-it's about why they are missing and what that says about the way research is designed. We outline three common ways dysinclusion happens: 1) When people are missing from the data we rely on. 2) When people are eligible to participate but cannot or would not. 3) When people are included in a study, but their identity is misclassified, ignored, or made invisible. Dysinclusion is a concept at the intersection of ethics and research methods. Naming and defining dysinclusion can help to guide research that treats equity as a core part of research quality. Just as we assess studies for bias or confounding, we should assess them for dysinclusion, and take steps to reduce it through better study design, more inclusive data collection, and clearer reporting. Addressing dysinclusion is not only about equity. It's also about better science.
引用
- Durbin A, Whittingham L, Menezes A, et al. Dysinclusion: naming and defining the inequitable absence of marginalized populations in health research. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 41224136. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.112048
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。