聚焦优势一阶环评估网状Meta分析证据确定性影响:一项案例研究
该案例研究考察网状Meta分析(NMA)中间接证据确定性评估时,仅聚焦优势一阶环与考虑多数或全部环两种方法的影响。在6篇NMA的103项间接比较中,仅6%的间接比较因方法不同导致确定性评级不同,其中两项从中等降为低。作者认为仅用优势一阶环很少导致误导,但需进一步研究在其他NMA中重复或反驳该发现,并评估对临床决策的影响。
要点
- 在103项间接比较中,15项(15%)无一阶环,42/88项(47%)优势一阶环权重小于50%。
- 仅6/103项(6%)间接比较因方法不同导致确定性评级不同,两项从中等降为低。
- 作者认为仅用优势一阶环很少误导,系统评价作者可继续使用更简单的方法。
核心结论
- 仅使用优势一阶环与考虑多数或全部环相比,很少导致证据确定性评级误导。
- 需进一步研究在其他网状Meta分析中重复或反驳该发现,并评估对临床决策的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 案例研究,考察6篇网状Meta分析(NMA)出版物。
- 比较仅考虑优势一阶环与考虑多数或全部环两种方法对间接证据确定性评级的影响。
主要发现
- 在6篇NMA的103项间接比较中,15项(15%)没有一阶环。
- 在88项有优势一阶环的间接比较中,42项(47%)的优势一阶环对间接证据贡献的权重小于50%。
- 共6项(6%)间接比较因两种方法导致确定性评级不同,其中两项从中等降为低。
关键数值与推荐
- GRADE指南建议聚焦通常贡献最多信息的优势一阶环,以使间接证据的确定性评级可行。
临床怎么用
- 系统评价作者可继续使用仅聚焦优势一阶环这一更简单的方法评估间接证据确定性。
局限性
- 需进一步研究在其他网状Meta分析中重复或反驳该发现,并评估对临床决策的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Assessing the certainty of evidence (COE) of both direct and indirect evidence of is crucial for enhancing the understanding of network meta-analysis (NMA) findings and drawing appropriate conclusions. To make the certainty rating of indirect evidence feasible, Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) guidance suggests focusing on the dominant first order loop that typically contributes the most information to the indirect estimate. This approach, however, can raise concerns that failure to consider most or all loops will provide inaccurate COE of indirect evidence. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We investigated six NMA publications and compared indirect COE ratings considering only the dominant first order loop vs ratings considering most or all loops. RESULTS: Across 103 indirect comparisons in the six NMAs, 15% (15 out of 103) comparisons did not have a first order loop, and 47% (42 out of 88) comparisons with dominant first order loops contributed a weight smaller than 50% of the indirect evidence. We identified a total of 6% (6 out of 103) indirect comparisons in which ratings based on the dominant first order loop resulted in different COE ratings from considering most or all loops, with two shifting from moderate to low COE of NMA. CONCLUSION: Our findings suggest that using only the dominant first order loop vs considering most or all loops is very seldom misleading. Further research is necessary to replicate or refute our findings in other network meta-analyses and assess the implications for clinical decision-making. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: NMA allows researchers to compare the relative effectiveness of multiple treatments. The GRADE working group provides guidance to establish the confidence in treatment effects (how likely they are to be true) by evaluating the COE to direct, indirect and NMA estimates, which can be high, moderate, low or very low. We investigated the influences of using two different approaches (dominant first order loop vs consideration of most or all loops) for rating the certainty of NMA. We found similar certainty ratings of indirect evidence and NMA between the two approaches. Therefore, systematic review authors can continue using the simpler approach.
引用
- Yao L, Hui X, Cao L, et al. Influence of focusing on dominant first order loop when assessing the certainty of evidence of network meta-analysis: a case study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 41224137. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.112050
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。