未发表数据对成人急性偏头痛门诊患者网络Meta分析结果的影响:一项基于综述的研究
该研究在近期系统综述基础上补充检索未发表数据,纳入17项(6735例受试者)有结果的未发表双盲药物随机对照试验,重做偏头痛治疗网络Meta分析。结果显示加入未发表数据后所有效应方向不变,仅6个置信区间新跨越无效线,144项证据确定性评估中4项发生有意义变化,总体结论未变。
要点
- 17项未发表试验(6735例)中多数(59%)通过试验注册库识别,为网络Meta分析新增两种干预。
- 加入未发表数据后所有风险比方向不变,但6个置信区间新跨越无效线(RR=1)。
- 144项证据确定性评估中4项变化:1项因不精确性从高降至中等,3项因新直接证据从极低/无证据升至低。
核心结论
- 在本案例研究中,加入未发表数据对结果和结论影响极小,仅网络几何结构和证据确定性发生轻微变化。
研究设计与样本
- 在近期系统综述检索基础上,补充检索ClinicalTrials.gov、世界卫生组织国际临床试验注册平台、监管机构报告、预印本引文索引、Europe PubMed Central、Embase.com及过去5年会议摘要中的未发表数据。
- 由两名独立评价员筛选合格研究、核实发表状态、提取数据并重新评估证据确定性。
- 对四种二分类结局重现原始网络Meta分析并纳入未发表数据,比较风险比、绝对风险差及95%CI、证据确定性评估和结论。
主要发现
- 37项合格未发表试验中17项(6735例受试者)已发布结果并纳入分析,其中多数(59%)通过试验注册库识别。
- 另从原始分析中的4项已发表试验检索到未发表的结局数据。
- 这些未发表试验为网络Meta分析新增两种此前未代表的干预,增加了直接比较数量和闭环数量。
- 与原始分析比较,所有风险比效应方向保持不变,但有6个置信区间新跨越无效效应(RR=1)。
- 144项证据确定性评估中4项发生有意义变化:1项因不精确性从高降至中等,3项基于新直接证据从极低/无证据升至低。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Methodological guidance recommends including both published and unpublished data in systematic reviews to enhance reliability and reduce potential bias. The objective of the study was to evaluate the impact of unpublished data from double-blind, pharmacologic randomized controlled trials on the results of network meta-analysis (NMA) of migraine treatments. METHODS: We supplemented the search of a recent systematic review with targeted searches for unpublished data on ClinicalTrials.gov, the World Health Organization International Clinical Trials Registry Platform, regulatory agency reports, The Preprints Citation Index, Europe PubMed Central, and Embase.com, and conference abstracts from the past 5 years. Two independent reviewers selected eligible studies, verified publication status, extracted data, and reassessed certainty of evidence (COE). We reproduced the original NMA including unpublished data for four dichotomous outcomes. We compared our results with the original NMA in terms of risk ratio (RR), absolute risk difference with 95% CI, COE assessments, and conclusions. RESULTS: Seventeen (6735 participants) of 37 eligible unpublished trials had posted results and were analyzed, with most (59%) identified via trial registries. In addition, unpublished outcome data were retrieved for four published trials from the original analysis. These unpublished trials added two previously unrepresented interventions to the NMA, increasing the number of direct comparisons and closed loops. Comparisons of RRs (95% CI) with the original analysis showed all effects maintained the same direction, although six CIs newly crossed the null effect (RR = 1). Among 144 COE assessments, four changed meaningfully: one was rated down from high to moderate due to imprecision, and three were rated up from very low/no evidence to low COE based on new direct evidence. Overall conclusions remained unchanged after including unpublished data. CONCLUSIONS: In this case study, adding unpublished data had minimal impact on results and conclusions, with only minor changes in network geometry and COE.
引用
- Dobrescu A, Nussbaumer-Streit B, Wagner G, et al. Assessing the impact of unpublished data on network meta-analysis outcomes in outpatient adults with acute migraine: a study within a review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 41077323. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.112014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。