运动方式治疗膝骨关节炎的疗效与安全性比较:系统评价与网状Meta分析
该系统评价与网状Meta分析纳入217项随机对照试验共15684例膝骨关节炎患者,比较有氧运动、柔韧性运动、身心运动、神经运动、力量运动、混合运动与对照组的疗效与安全性。中等确定性证据显示有氧运动可能在短期和中期改善疼痛、功能、步态及生活质量方面获益最大,安全性结局报告的研究较少且运动干预与对照组间未见明显差异。
要点
- 有氧运动在改善疼痛、功能、步态和生活质量方面概率最高,证据确定性为中等。
- 身心运动可能短期大幅改善功能,神经运动可能短期大幅改善步态表现,均为中等确定性。
- 安全性结局仅40项研究(18%)报告,运动干预与对照组间未见明显差异。
核心结论
- 在膝骨关节炎患者中,有氧运动可能是改善疼痛、功能、步态表现和生活质量最有益的运动方式,证据确定性为中等。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与网状Meta分析,检索PubMed、Embase、Cochrane Library、Web of Science、CINAHL、PsycINFO、AMED、PEDro、Scopus、ClinicalTrials.gov、ICTRP和ClinicalTrialsRegister.eu,从建库至2024年8月。
- 纳入比较不同运动方式(有氧运动、柔韧性运动、身心运动、神经运动、力量运动、混合运动)与对照组的随机对照试验,共217项试验、15684例参与者。
- 主要结局为疼痛、功能、步态表现和生活质量,评估时间点为短期(4周)、中期(12周)和长期(24周)随访;确切时间点不可用时采用相邻时间窗数据。
主要发现
- 与对照组相比,有氧运动可能在短期(标准化均数差-1.10,95%CI -1.68至-0.52)和中期(-1.19,-1.59至-0.79)大幅改善疼痛,中期大幅改善功能(1.78,1.05至2.51)和步态表现(0.85,0.55至1.14),短期大幅改善生活质量(1.53,0.47至2.59),均为中等确定性证据。
- 身心运动可能在短期大幅改善功能(0.88,0.03至1.73;中等确定性),神经运动可能在短期大幅改善步态表现(1.04,0.51至1.57;中等确定性)。
- 力量运动(0.86,0.53至1.18)和混合运动(1.07,0.68至1.46)可能在中期大幅改善功能,均为中等确定性证据。
- 长期随访中,柔韧性运动可能大幅减轻疼痛(-0.99,-1.63至-0.36;低确定性);有氧运动可能大幅改善功能(0.87,0.02至1.72;低确定性);混合运动可能改善功能(0.56,0.26至0.86;低确定性)并可能改善步态表现(0.57,0.21至0.92;中等确定性)。
- 有氧运动在各结局的累积排名曲线下面积均值最高(均值0.72),即成为最佳治疗的概率最高;安全性结局仅40项研究(18%)报告,运动干预与对照组间未见明显差异。
局限性
- 安全性结局仅在少数研究中报告(40项研究,18%)。
- 长期随访证据确定性为低(柔韧性运动减轻疼痛、有氧运动改善功能、混合运动改善功能)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess the efficacy and safety of various exercise modalities as therapeutic interventions for managing knee osteoarthritis. DESIGN: Systematic review with network meta-analysis. DATA SOURCES: PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, CINAHL, PsycINFO, AMED, PEDro, Scopus, ClinicalTrials.gov, ICTRP, and ClinicalTrialsRegister.eu from database inception to August 2024. ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR SELECTING STUDIES: Randomised controlled trials comparing different exercise modalities, including aerobic exercise, flexibility exercise, mind-body exercise, neuromotor exercise, strengthening exercise, mixed exercise, and control group for patients with knee osteoarthritis. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Primary outcomes included pain, function, gait performance, and quality of life, assessed at short term (four weeks), mid-term (12 weeks), and long term (24 weeks) follow-up. When exact time points were unavailable, data from adjacent time windows were used. RESULTS: 217 randomised controlled trials involving 15 684 participants were included. Moderate certainty evidence showed that, compared with the control group, aerobic exercise probably results in large improvements in pain at short term (standardised mean difference -1.10, 95% confidence interval -1.68 to -0.52) and mid-term follow-up (-1.19, -1.59 to -0.79), function at mid-term (1.78, 1.05 to 2.51), gait performance at mid-term (0.85, 0.55 to 1.14), and quality of life at short term (1.53, 0.47 to 2.59). Mind-body exercise probably results in a large increase in function at short term follow-up (0.88, 0.03 to 1.73; moderate certainty), while neuromotor exercise probably results in a large increase in gait performance at short term follow-up (1.04, 0.51 to 1.57; moderate certainty). Strengthening (0.86, 0.53 to 1.18) and mixed exercise (1.07, 0.68 to 1.46) probably result in a large increase in function at mid-term follow-up, all with moderate certainty evidence. Regarding long term follow-up, flexibility exercise may result in a large reduction in pain (-0.99, -1.63 to -0.36; low certainty); aerobic exercise may result in a large increase in function (0.87, 0.02 to 1.72, low certainty); and mixed exercise may increase function (0.56, 0.26 to 0.86; low certainty) and probably increases gait performance (0.57, 0.21 to 0.92, moderate certainty). Overall, aerobic exercise consistently showed the highest probability of being the best treatment, as reflected by surface under the cumulative ranking curve values (mean 0.72) across outcomes. The safety outcome was reported in a small proportion of studies (40 studies, 18%), and no clear differences were observed between exercise interventions and control. CONCLUSIONS: In patients with knee osteoarthritis, aerobic exercise is likely the most beneficial exercise modality for improving pain, function, gait performance, and quality of life, with moderate certainty. SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42023469762.
引用
- Yan L, Li D, Xing D, et al. Comparative efficacy and safety of exercise modalities in knee osteoarthritis: systematic review and network meta-analysis. BMJ. 2025. PMID: 41093618. doi:10.1136/bmj-2025-085242
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。