为什么常识性试验在英国失败?从一项测试社区跌倒预防项目有效性和成本效果的试验(Firefli研究)中吸取的教训
Firefli研究原计划个体随机对照试验评估家庭消防安全访视(又称安全与健康访视)减少社区老年人跌倒和改善生活质量的有效性与成本效果,目标随机1156人,实际仅随机63人。作者反思在消防部门开展确定性试验的障碍,指出当前监管要求、数据获取及消防部门缺乏研究文化和基础设施是根本障碍,建议紧急审查主要针对国家医疗服务体系健康研究的研究治理流程。
要点
- 目标随机1156人,实际仅随机63人,试验无法按计划实施。
- 监管要求、数据获取及消防部门缺乏研究文化与基础设施是根本障碍。
- 作者建议紧急审查主要针对国家医疗服务体系健康研究的研究治理流程。
核心结论
- 在英国开展卫生领域之外的试验极具挑战性。
- 作者建议紧急审查主要为国家医疗服务体系健康相关研究设计的研究治理流程,这些流程在其他部门开展研究时不适用。
- 许多挑战并非消防部门独有,随着循证实践范围扩展到卫生领域之外,具有更广泛影响。
研究设计与样本
- Firefli研究由委托征集资助,旨在开展个体随机对照试验,评估家庭消防安全访视(又称安全与健康访视)减少社区老年人跌倒和改善生活质量的有效性与成本效果。
- 这些访视由英格兰消防与救援服务常规开展,旨在降低火灾风险、支持独立生活并改善生活质量。
- 本文反思在消防部门尝试开展确定性试验的经验,以期为英国非国家医疗服务体系主持的试验的未来委托和方法学实践提供信息。
主要发现
- 在当前研究环境下无法按计划开展试验,目标随机1156人,实际仅随机63人。
- 尽管存在COVID-19大流行的挑战,但当前监管要求、数据获取以及消防部门缺乏研究文化和基础设施是成功开展研究的根本障碍。
- 这些障碍意味着无法实施旨在反映实际服务提供的试验设计。
- 调整后的试验设计招募率极低,并导致目标人群与试验人群之间存在差异。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Firefli study was funded from a commissioned call to conduct a individually randomised controlled trial to assess the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of Home Fire Safety Visits (also known as Safe and Well Visits) in their ability to reduce falls and improve quality of life in older adults living in the community. These visits are routinely carried out by fire and rescue services in England and aim to reduce risk of fire, support independent living and improve quality of life. In this paper, we reflect on our experience of attempting to deliver a definitive trial within the fire service, with the aim of informing future commissioning and methodological practice for non-National Health Service hosted trials in the UK. LESSON LEARNED: It proved impossible to conduct the trial as planned in the current research landscape, randomising only 63 participants from a target of 1156. Whilst there were challenges associated with the COVID-19 pandemic, it was key issues pertaining to current regulatory requirements, the acquisition of data and lack of research culture and infrastructure with the fire service which were fundamental barriers to successful research delivery. Specifically, these barriers meant it was not feasible to implement the trial as designed to reflect actual service delivery. The adapted trial design had very low recruitment and resulted in differences between the target population and the trial population. CONCLUSIONS: Conducting trials outside of health is extremely challenging in the UK. We recommend an urgent review of research governance processes which are primarily designed for health-related research in the National Health Service and are not fit for purpose when conducting research within other sectors. Many of the challenges identified are not exclusive to delivering trials in the fire service and have wider implications as the scope for evidence-based practice expands outside of health. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT04717258.
引用
- Adamson J, Scantlebury A, Drummond A, et al. Why do common sense trials fail in the UK? Lessons learned from a trial which tested the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of a community falls prevention programme (the Firefli study). Trials. 2025. PMID: 41013512. doi:10.1186/s13063-025-09116-x
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。