文献速递医学教育与科研方法流行病学与生物统计

QUADAS-3预试验:修订版诊断准确性研究质量评估工具

Piloting QUADAS-3: a revised tool for the quality assessment of diagnostic accuracy studies.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2025-09-23

本文介绍QUADAS-3开发过程中的多阶段预试验,包括指导组对5篇期刊论文的试用、全球证据峰会16人工作坊、7名研究者的出声思维访谈,以及7名综述作者在5项系统综述中的试用与在线调查反馈。反馈总体积极,据此对工具结构与措辞作出关键修改,并明确将进一步提供工作示例等指导。

要点

  • QUADAS-3在四阶段预试验中收集用户反馈,总体评价积极。
  • 根据反馈增加了域内描述性提示、工具开头阶段说明部分并改进了措辞。
  • 用户指出仍需进一步指导,包括开发工作示例,将纳入配套QUADAS-3指导文件。

核心结论

  • 广泛的预试验确保将潜在用户的反馈整合进QUADAS-3的开发中。

研究设计与样本

  • 多阶段预试验:指导组对5篇期刊论文试用;全球证据峰会16名参与者参加工作坊;7名研究者进行出声思维访谈;7名综述作者在5项进行中或已完成的系统综述中试用并在线调查反馈。

主要发现

  • 四个预试验阶段对工具的反馈总体积极,参与者认可工具结构、在估计水平进行评估以及引入定义理想试验准确性试验的框架。
  • 参与者提出结构与措辞改进建议,促成关键修改:在QUADAS-3各域内插入描述性提示、在工具开头增加概述工具各阶段及完成时机的部分、全文措辞更清晰。
  • 参与者还指出需要进一步指导的领域,包括开发工作示例,将纳入配套QUADAS-3指导文件。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: QUADAS-2 is the most widely used tool for evaluating risk of bias and applicability concerns in diagnostic test accuracy studies within systematic reviews. QUADAS-2 has recently been updated to a new version, named QUADAS-3. This paper outlines the piloting process undertaken as part of the development of QUADAS-3. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Multistage piloting: (1) piloting by the QUADAS-3 steering group on a set of five journal papers, (2) piloting workshop at the Global Evidence Summit attended by 16 participants, (3) think aloud interviews with seven researchers who piloted the tool while verbalizing their thoughts, and (4) piloting in five ongoing or completed systematic reviews by seven review authors who provided feedback in an online survey. RESULTS: Feedback on the tool was generally positive across the four piloting stages. Participants appreciated the structure of the tool, assessment at the estimate level, and the introduction of a framework to define the ideal test accuracy trial. Participants provided suggestions for improvement to the structure and wording of the tool; this led to key changes including the insertion of descriptive prompts within the QUADAS-3 domains, a section at the beginning of the tool to outline the tool's phases and when they should be completed, and clearer wording throughout the tool. Participants also identified areas where further guidance is required for users, including development of worked examples, which will be covered in the associated QUADAS-3 guidance document. CONCLUSION: Extensive piloting has ensured that feedback from potential users has been integrated into the development of QUADAS-3. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: What is the problem? Doctors often use tests to find out if a person has a certain condition. It is important that these tests can correctly tell people who have the condition from those who do not. This is called test accuracy. Diagnostic reviews are a type of research that bring together results from different studies about the accuracy of a test. In diagnostic reviews, researchers need to check whether the studies they include are reliable. They also need to check whether the studies match the question the review looks at. Researchers can use a tool called QUADAS-2 to do this. QUADAS-2 was made in 2011 and is now out of date. We have made a new version called QUADAS-3. In this paper, we explain how we tested the QUADAS-3 tool before making the final version. What did we do? We tested the tool in four steps. 1. The people making the tool used it on five research papers. 2. It was tested by 16 people at a conference. 3. Seven researchers said their thoughts out loud while using the tool and we gathered their feedback. 4. Seven researchers used the tool in real reviews. They gave feedback in an online survey. We updated the tool after each step. What did we find? Most people liked the QUADAS-3 tool. They also told us ways to make it better. We made changes in response to people's comments. This led to the final version of QUADAS-3.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Tomlinson E, Yang B, Davenport CF, et al. Piloting QUADAS-3: a revised tool for the quality assessment of diagnostic accuracy studies. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 40998133. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.111983

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。