引用Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials结局分类法的研究意见分析支持其在健康研究中的应用:描述性研究
该描述性研究通过引文分析识别应用Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials分类法的已发表研究,抽样分析200篇中的193篇(涉及184个项目),了解出版物类型、临床领域、使用或改编原因及研究者评论。结果显示该分类法足够全面和细致,可用于健康研究中所有患者结局的分类,作者鼓励采用该分类系统以促进证据检索。
要点
- 在193篇出版物(184个项目)中,近三分之一(58篇,30%)与核心结局集(COS)开发相关,一半(98篇,51%)与综述开发相关。
- 在三分之二(123个,67%)的项目中,分类法用于健康结局分类,其中绝大多数(117个,95%)未做任何修改。
- 作者确认该分类法足够全面和细致,可用于健康研究中所有患者结局的分类,并鼓励采用该分类系统以促进证据检索。
核心结论
- 该研究确认该分类法足够全面和细致,可用于健康研究中所有患者结局的分类。
- 其应用可突显对患者最重要结局关注不足的问题。
- 作者鼓励采用该分类系统以促进证据检索。
研究设计与样本
- 描述性研究,通过引文分析识别已发表的应用该分类法的研究。
- 共识别315篇论文,抽样200篇,最终分析193篇出版物(涉及184个项目)。
主要发现
- 近三分之一(58篇,30%)的出版物与核心结局集(COS)开发相关,一半(98篇,51%)与综述(系统综述、范围综述和文献综述)开发相关。
- 在三分之二(123个,67%)的项目中,分类法用于健康结局分类,其中绝大多数(117个,95%)未做任何修改。
- 部分研究者希望分类报告结局的「报告者」(如患者),或希望获得各结局类型更具体的定义。
- 少数研究者认为需要添加额外结局类型,但这是因为他们未意识到这些结局可归入现有分类组之一。
关键数值与推荐
- 在123个将分类法用于健康结局分类的项目中,117个(95%)未做任何修改。
- 作者建议研究者可在该分类法的类别内创建子类别,以涵盖报告者等结局特征。
临床怎么用
- 作者鼓励采用该分类系统以促进证据检索。
- 作者建议研究者可在该分类法的类别内创建子类别,以涵盖报告者等结局特征。
- 作者表示研究者如有使用或分类特定结局的疑问,欢迎联系他们。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To support the use of the Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials taxonomy for health outcomes, its suitability and applicability must be assessed more broadly beyond that of its early piloting phases. Demonstration of its suitability in practice would provide further support for its use in aiding the development of core outcome sets (COS), systematic reviews, and searching in online resources, thereby aiding knowledge dissemination. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A citation analysis identified published studies where the taxonomy had been applied. Analysis of these publications aimed to understand the type of publication, clinical area, reason for taxonomy use or adaptation, and any comments made by researchers who had applied the taxonomy. RESULTS: Of 315 papers identified, 200 were sampled and 193 publications relating to 184 projects were analyzed. Nearly one-third (58, 30%) of publications were related to the development of COS and half (98, 51%) were related to the development of reviews (systematic, scoping, and literature). In two-thirds (123, 67%) of the projects the taxonomy was applied for the classification of health outcomes and the vast majority (117, 95%) of these did so without making any changes. CONCLUSION: This research confirms the taxonomy is sufficiently comprehensive and granular for the classification of all patient outcomes in health research. Its application can highlight a lack of attention being paid toward outcomes most important to patients. We encourage the adoption of this classification system to facilitate evidence searching. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Patient health outcomes measure things that happen to patients relating to their health. These outcomes include clinical measures (such as blood pressure), life impact measures (such as effects on physical functioning), use of resources (such as number of hospital appointments), survival (such as how long someone survives after surgery), and harms (such as adverse events following treatment). In 2018, we developed a classification system (called a taxonomy) to help researchers organize the types of outcomes that they are collecting (perhaps when carrying out a clinical trial) or reporting (eg, when combining results from many studies in a systematic review). This taxonomy was designed to help researchers to more clearly present their results, as well as to allow them to search for outcomes online in a more organized manner. We used outcomes taken from many trials and reviews when developing the taxonomy, to make sure that all types of outcomes were covered, but we wanted to make sure that researchers found the taxonomy helpful in practice. This study has been carried out to understand the opinions of researchers who mentioned the taxonomy in their publications, to find out whether they thought any types of outcomes were missing. The study found that researchers found the taxonomy useful, either to classify their research outcomes or because they found our definitions of the different types of outcomes useful. Sometimes researchers wanted to be able to classify "who" reported the outcomes (such as patients) or wanted more specific definitions of the different types of outcomes included. We would encourage them to create subcategories within our taxonomy categories to cover these outcome features. A few researchers felt that they needed to add some extra outcome types, but this was because they did not realize that these outcomes would fit within one of the existing taxonomy groups. In summary, this study found that the taxonomy is useful to researchers to classify "what" patient health outcomes are recorded in their studies, and researchers are very welcome to contact us if they have any questions about how to use it or how to classify particular outcomes.
引用
- Christodoulou T, Williamson PR, Dodd S, et al. Analysis of opinions from studies citing use of Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials outcomes taxonomy supports it use in health research: descriptive study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 40754038. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.111917
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。