旨在评估为无法自行同意的成人代理做出研究参与决策的家庭提供决策支持干预的试验内研究(CONSULT SWAT)的可行性
CONSULT SWAT是一项混合方法随机试验内研究(SWAT),在单个宿主研究中评估决策辅助工具对家庭代理决策者的可行性与可接受性。92名家庭成员按1:1随机分为决策辅助手册组或标准信息加空白笔记本组,仅16人完成CONCORD问卷。结论认为该SWAT可行,但需在正式SWAT前调整研究流程。
要点
- 92名家庭成员随机分组,仅16人完成CONCORD问卷,招募率与数据完整性是可行性评估指标。
- 访谈对象包括代理决策者4名和宿主研究工作人员3名,后者提供了资源使用数据。
- 作者认为SWAT可行,但需在正式SWAT前调整研究流程,并称将SWAT无缝整合入宿主研究可能使其对代理决策者变得「不可见」。
核心结论
- CONSULT SWAT可行,但需在正式SWAT前调整研究流程。
- 作者认为将SWAT无缝整合入宿主研究可能无意中使其对代理决策者变得「不可见」。
- 涉及缺乏同意能力参与者的试验数量少,限制了证据基础的发展;宿主试验的招募仍在继续,重点是在广泛人群和环境中评估该干预。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法随机试验内研究(SWAT)的可行性阶段,在单个宿主研究中开展。
- 被邀请作为宿主研究代理决策者的家庭成员按1:1随机分配至决策辅助手册加标准研究信息组(干预组)或标准信息加空白笔记本组(对照组),并邀请完成CONCORD量表(代理知情同意决策联合量表)问题及参加半结构化访谈。
- 通过招募率和数据完整性评估SWAT可接受性,并对家庭成员和研究工作人员进行访谈,访谈采用快速定性分析方法。
- 共92名家庭成员随机分配至SWAT,其中16人完成CONCORD问卷;访谈了代理决策者4名和宿主研究工作人员3名。
- 该SWAT已在北爱尔兰试验方法学研究中心的SWAT注册库注册为SWAT #159(注册日期2020年8月9日)。
主要发现
- 共92名家庭成员随机分配至SWAT,其中16人完成CONCORD问卷。
- 访谈了代理决策者4名和宿主研究工作人员3名,工作人员还提供了资源使用数据。
- 工作人员与代理决策者相处的时间差异很小。
- 关键主题包括:(1)设立SWAT并与宿主研究平衡优先事项;(2)为SWAT招募代理决策者时的差异;(3)SWAT的可行性与可接受性;(4)测量决策质量的挑战;(5)对决策支持干预的看法与体验。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 涉及缺乏同意能力参与者的试验数量少,限制了证据基础的发展。
- 作者认为将SWAT无缝整合入宿主研究可能无意中使其对代理决策者变得「不可见」。
- 需在正式SWAT前调整研究流程。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Trials involving adults who lack capacity to consent can be challenging, partly due to the involvement of 'proxy' decision-makers. This is usually a family member, who advises the researchers about the person's wishes. Families can find decision making difficult and some experience a decisional burden. Following the development of a decision aid for family members making trial participation decisions, we are conducting a mixed-methods randomised Study Within a Trial (SWAT) to evaluate its (cost-)effectiveness. This paper reports the feasibility stage conducted in one host study to inform delivery of the main SWAT. METHODS: Family members approached to act as a consultee for the host study were randomised 1:1 to receive the decision aid booklet alongside standard study information (intervention), or standard information plus a blank notebook (control), and asked to complete the CONCORD scale (Combined Scale for Proxy Informed Consent Decisions) questions about their experience and take part in a semi-structured interview. Acceptability of the SWAT was assessed through exploring recruitment rates and data completeness, and qualitatively through interviews with family members and research staff. Interviews were analysed using a rapid qualitative approach. RESULTS: In total, 92 family members were randomised to the SWAT and 16 completed the CONCORD questionnaire. Interviews were conducted with consultees (n = 4), and host study staff (n = 3) who also provided resource use data. Differences in time staff spent with consultees were small. Key themes included (1) setting up the SWAT and balancing priorities with the host study, (2) differences when recruiting consultees to a SWAT, (3) feasibility and acceptability of the SWAT, (4) challenges of measuring decision quality and (5) views and experiences of the decision support intervention. CONCLUSION: The CONSULT SWAT is feasible, but changes to study processes are needed in advance of the main SWAT. The findings suggest that attempting to seamlessly integrate the SWAT into the host study may have inadvertently led to it becoming 'invisible' to consultees. The small number of trials involving participants lacking capacity limits opportunities for developing the evidence-base. Recruitment of host trials continues, with a focus on evaluating the intervention in a broad range of populations and settings. TRIAL REGISTRATION: The SWAT is registered as SWAT #159 with the Northern Ireland Hub for Trials Methodology Research SWAT repository (registered 09.08.2020).
引用
- Shepherd V, Smallman K, Wood F, et al. Feasibility of a Study Within a Trial to evaluate a decision support intervention for families deciding about research on behalf of adults lacking capacity to consent (CONSULT SWAT). Trials. 2025. PMID: 40859327. doi:10.1186/s13063-025-09021-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。