为受试者寻找试验:一项关于临床试验成功招募策略的民族志研究
该研究在英国伦敦一家临床试验中心开展为期17个月的民族志观察,聚焦三项高血压临床试验的筛查与预筛查,并结合半结构化访谈。结果显示该中心通过「为受试者寻找试验」的反向招募逻辑,在传统招募模式之外提供多种试验选择。作者认为理解这一成功招募逻辑或可帮助其他机构提升招募数量与代表性,并需未来系统检验这些方法。
要点
- 该中心在传统「为试验找受试者」模式之外,采用「为受试者寻找试验」的反向招募逻辑。
- 受试者首次到中心时被提供一系列试验,完成现有试验后再被提供其他合适试验。
- 反向逻辑改变了受试者适配性的内涵,不仅要求符合入选条件,还要求是工作人员愿意接纳的人。
核心结论
- 临床试验招募困难是长期问题,理解成功中心通过反向招募逻辑进行招募,或可让其他机构尝试以此提升试验招募数量与代表性。
研究设计与样本
- 在英国伦敦一家临床试验中心开展为期17个月的民族志观察,并辅以对工作人员和受试者的半结构化访谈与民族志访谈。
- 观察聚焦三项高血压临床试验,包括其筛查与预筛查访视;数据集整体包括353.5小时观察、322分钟半结构化访谈,以及未录音的民族志访谈。
主要发现
- 该中心采用创新策略,反转了传统招募逻辑。
- 该中心在开展传统试验招募模式(通过广播、报纸、社交媒体广告以及从其他医疗环境招募等方式为特定试验寻找受试者)的同时,反转逻辑为受试者寻找试验,类似试验匹配平台的运作逻辑。
- 该中心在受试者首次到访时提供一系列试验,并在其完成所参与试验后提供其他合适试验。
- 这一反向逻辑改变了受试者适配性的性质,使其不仅限于符合入选条件的人,还包括工作人员愿意且乐于接纳的人。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,理解成功中心通过反转招募逻辑进行招募的方式,或可让其他机构尝试以此提升试验招募数量与代表性。
- 作者指出,这开辟了未来系统检验这些方法的 research 领域。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Finding participants is one of the main barriers to the timely and successful running of clinical trials. Poor recruitment can lead to many issues, such as delays, which often leads to greater financial resources being put into the trials. We explore how a clinical trial centre with a good recruitment record is able to find participants for trials through successful innovative strategies. METHODS: Ethnographic observations were conducted over a 17-month period at a clinical trial unit in London, UK, supplemented with semi-structured and ethnographic interviews with staff and participants. Observations focused on three hypertension clinical trials, including screening and pre-screening visits for them. Overall, the dataset included 353.5 h of observations, 322 min of semi-structures interviews, and ethnographic interviews not recorded. RESULTS: It was found that The Centre engaged in innovative strategies by reversing the traditional logic of recruitment. As well as engaging in the traditional model of trial recruitment (1-4), where participants were found for specific trials (such as radio, newspaper, and social media adverts, and recruiting from other healthcare settings), The Centre reversed the logic and found trials for participants, a similar logic to how trial-matching platforms work. This was done by offering participants a range of trials when they first came to The Centre and offering other appropriate trials when they had finished the ones they were on. This reversed logic changed the nature of suitability of a participant to not only be someone eligible, but someone who staff would want and appreciate. CONCLUSION: Trouble recruiting for clinical trials is a perennial problem. Understanding how a successful centre recruits by reversing the logic of recruitment may allow other settings to attempt this to boost numbers and representativeness on trials. This opens up areas of future research to systematically test these methods.
引用
- Reynolds DJ, Perrotta M, Maeilli G, et al. Finding trials for participants: an ethnographic study of successful recruitment strategies for clinical trials. Trials. 2025. PMID: 40781321. doi:10.1186/s13063-025-08993-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。