Trial Forge 指南5:随机对照试验内研究(SWAT)的伦理考量
该指南旨在为随机对照试验内研究(SWAT)提供伦理考量框架。通过系统综述、检索PubMed和SWAT注册库、接触已知SWAT团队,并召开三次共识建设论坛(含八个关键利益相关方代表),最终形成14条覆盖SWAT全阶段的伦理考量,以问题形式呈现以便试验团队设计时回答。指南认为SWAT通常低风险、低负担,但研究者、申办方和伦理委员会应用的标准存在差异。
要点
- SWAT是嵌入宿主试验中比较试验流程替代方案的自-contained研究。
- 指南形成14条伦理考量,覆盖从开发、团队选择到结果传播的全阶段。
- 伦理考量以问题形式呈现,便于试验团队设计SWAT时逐条回答。
核心结论
- SWAT通常被认为对参与者低风险、低负担,但研究者、申办方和伦理委员会应用的标准仍存在差异。
- 该指南有助于计划或评审SWAT者理解这些差异及其伦理含义,并为SWAT的伦理实施提供实用指南。
研究设计与样本
- 制定机构与方法:基于现有系统综述、检索PubMed和SWAT注册库、联系作者已知的SWAT团队识别相关随机SWAT进行文献综述。
- 提取SWAT描述性信息及作者预先识别的19项潜在伦理考量结局,并进行主题归纳。
- 召开三次共识建设论坛,参与者包括代表试验中广泛角色的八个关键利益相关方组代表。
- 论坛中向参与者呈现两个SWAT以启动对感知伦理问题的讨论,并纳入文献综述发现。
- 共识建设论坛录音、转录并使用NVivo分析,聚焦伦理原则、挑战与解决方案。
主要发现
- 形成了适用于随机SWAT的伦理考量指南,共14条伦理考量。
- 14条伦理考量覆盖SWAT全阶段,从开发与SWAT团队选择到结果沟通。
- 伦理考量以问题形式提出,便于试验团队在设计SWAT时回答。
- SWAT被普遍认为低风险、低负担,但研究者、申办方和伦理委员会应用的标准存在差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 指南包含14条伦理考量,覆盖SWAT从开发、团队选择到结果传播的全阶段。
- 伦理考量以问题形式呈现,供试验团队设计SWAT时回答。
临床怎么用
- 该指南可帮助计划或评审SWAT者理解不同伦理标准差异及其伦理含义。
- 指南为SWAT的伦理实施提供实用指导。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Randomised trials often struggle with recruitment, retention, and delays, impacting both finances and patient care. To improve trial processes, trialists can do Studies Within A Trial (SWATs) that compare trial process alternatives. A SWAT is a self-contained research study that is embedded within a host trial, or several host trials, with the aim of evaluating or exploring alternative ways of delivering or organising a particular trial process. Although SWATs are recognised by funders, there are differences in how they are implemented, such as different consent requirements in the UK and Ireland. This complicates SWAT conduct, raises ethical considerations, and highlights the need for standardised, ethical approaches to SWATs. The purpose of the current study was to devise guidance to address this. METHODS: We used existing systematic reviews, searched PubMed and the SWAT register, and contacted SWAT teams known to the authors to identify relevant randomised SWATs to include in our literature review. We extracted information on SWAT descriptives and 19 outcomes of interest pre-identified by the authors as being potential ethical considerations. We themed our findings. We held three consensus building fora, all including representatives from eight key stakeholder groups representing a broad range of roles in trials. We presented participants with two SWATs to start conversation on perceived ethical issues. We also incorporated the findings of our literature review. Consensus building fora were recorded, transcribed, and analysed using NVivo, focusing on ethical principles, challenges, and solutions. RESULTS: We developed guidance on ethical considerations applicable to randomised SWATs. There are 14 ethical considerations covering all stages of a SWAT, from development and SWAT team selection to communication of results. The considerations are posed as questions, so trial teams can easily answer these when designing their SWAT. CONCLUSIONS: Studies Within A Trial are generally perceived to be low risk and low burden to participants. However, there are still varying ethical standards applied to these studies by researchers, sponsors, and ethics committees. These guidelines will be helpful to anyone planning or reviewing SWATs in understanding these differences and their ethical implications, and provide a practical guide for the ethical conduct of SWATs.
引用
- Bruhn H, Treweek S, Weijer C, et al. Trial Forge Guidance 5: ethical considerations in randomised Studies Within A Trial (SWATs). Trials. 2025. PMID: 40753414. doi:10.1186/s13063-025-08958-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。