文献速递医学教育与科研方法流行病学与生物统计

捕捉动态系统综述的涌入:一项系统性方法学调查

Capturing the influx of living systematic reviews: a systematic methodological survey.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2025-07-23

该系统性方法学调查检索2021年5月至2023年3月新发表或更新的动态系统综述(LSR),共纳入168篇LSR(其中92篇为新检出),描述其方法学与传播特征。结果显示LSR数量加速增长,但预设更新策略的明确性和基于网络平台的结果传播仍存方法学局限。

要点

  • 共纳入168篇LSR,其中92篇为2021年5月后新检出。
  • 337次更新中25.5%报告了正在进行的研究。
  • 已发表结果的LSR中58.5%使用了GRADE系统。

核心结论

  • LSR数量正以加速速率增长,但本调查显示仍存在需仔细应对的方法学局限与挑战。
  • 作者指出关键改进领域包括更明确的预设更新策略以及更好地利用网络平台传播结果。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统性方法学调查,系统检索2021年5月至2023年3月任何健康领域新发表或更新的LSR,并与原始调查数据合并。
  • 共识别549条记录,对应168篇独立LSR,其中92篇为新检出。

主要发现

  • 尽管COVID-19 LSR在后期年份占主导,非COVID-19 LSR的采纳也有所增加;前者检索证据和更新/发表结果的频率更高。
  • 在有报告的LSR中,更新方法差异很大,包括多种预设频率和/或触发条件。
  • 337次更新中25.5%报告了正在进行的研究;已发表结果的LSR中58.5%使用了GRADE系统。
  • 设有集中平台分享结果的LSR比例在以下各组更高:包含更新的LSR、Cochrane综述、非COVID-19 LSR以及有资助的LSR。
  • 很少有LSR包含交互式功能。

关键数值与推荐

  • 337次更新中25.5%报告了正在进行的研究。
  • 已发表结果的LSR中58.5%使用了GRADE系统。
  • 共识别549条记录,对应168篇独立LSR,其中92篇为新检出。

局限性

  • 本调查显示仍存在需仔细应对的方法学局限与挑战。
  • 关键改进领域包括更明确的预设更新策略以及更好地利用网络平台传播结果。
  • 很少有LSR包含交互式功能。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Living systematic reviews (LSRs) are an emerging type of review that continuously updates as new evidence becomes available. A previous methodological survey conducted in 2021 identified and studied all health-based LSRs. Since then, the landscape has changed, including the on-going accumulation of COVID-19 research and availability of automation tools. Furthermore, various methods and guidance exist for conducting LSRs and review authors are often encouraged to explore opportunities to maximize dissemination. We conducted an LSR survey update to describe LSRs in a "post-COVID" era. Our objectives were to summarize the uptake of LSRs, describe their characteristics, including methodological and communicative characteristics, and identify patterns in LSR attributes. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We systematically searched for new LSRs and any updates-including updates from LSRs identified previously-published between May 2021 and March 2023 in any health field. Eligible articles were identified and data extracted and combined with data from the original survey. Outcomes broadly included LSR characteristics and uptake, and methodological and communicative characteristics. Analyses were descriptive and included visualizations to explore distributions, combinations, and any time effects of characteristics. RESULTS: A total of 549 records across 168 individual LSRs were identified (of which 92 LSRs were newly detected). Although the presence of COVID-19 LSRs dominated in later years, there was an increased uptake in non-COVID-19 LSRs; the former were found to search the evidence and update/publish results more frequently. Where reported, the approach to conducting updates varied considerably, including a wide range of prespecified frequencies and/or triggers. Of the 337 updates, 25.5% reported on ongoing studies, and among LSRs with published results, 58.5% used the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation system. The proportion of LSRs with a centralized platform for sharing results was higher among (i) those that included updates, (ii) Cochrane reviews, (iii) non-COVID-19 LSRs, and (iv) funded LSRs. Few LSRs included interactive features. CONCLUSION: The number of LSRs is growing at an accelerating rate, but this survey illustrates that there are still methodological limitations and challenges that carefully need addressing. Key areas for improvement include more explicit prespecified updating strategies and better use of web-based platforms for disseminating results. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Every year, a huge amount of health-related research is published and it is difficult for busy doctors and health care workers to keep up to date with all of the new evidence. To help with this, the research can be summarized by carrying out a review. This is known as a "systematic review" if it is carefully carried out by two or more researchers. We use systematic reviews to get an accurate and fair summary of all the research available. However, these reviews can take a long time to create and can quickly become out-of-date. There is a new and exciting type of review called a "LSR" which is continually updated with new research evidence as it becomes available. This type of review is hugely important for "high-priority" health questions that need to be put into practice straight away, such as new treatments for COVID-19. As LSRs have become more popular since the COVID-19 pandemic, it is important to understand how LSRs are actually being performed and how well they share their results. In 2021, a group of researchers collected all the health-related LSRs that exist. In March 2023, we aimed to collect any new LSRs since then, and summarize what they look like now. Including LSRs found by the previous group, we found 168 LSRs, where 92 were found since May 2021. There now exist more COVID-19-related LSRs than non-COVID-19-related ones, but both groups are increasing in popularity. How LSRs decided when to "update" their results varied a lot. Non-COVID-19-related LSRs and those that had funding were more likely to use online tools to share their results, but very few used tools to let readers interact with the results. By looking at how LSRs are performed, we have shown that there are still challenges that need more work. Key areas for improvement include creating better ways on deciding when and how these reviews should be updated, and building tools to help researchers summarize the findings in a way that is reliable and easily understandable to everyone involved, including patients.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nevill CR, Sharifan A, O'Mahony A, et al. Capturing the influx of living systematic reviews: a systematic methodological survey. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 40712752. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.111904

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。