医师助理对医疗质量的影响:快速综述
该快速系统综述检索三个数据库,纳入2005年1月至2025年1月间发达国家发表的40项定量比较医师助理与医师(含住院医师)所提供医疗质量的研究。研究多为弱质量的回顾性观察性研究,主要来自美国。结果显示在直接监督下及诊断后诊疗中,医师助理执业安全有效;患者满意度无差异;成本效果证据有限。证据不支持在未分化(诊断前)场景中对医师助理进行间接监督的安全性或有效性。
要点
- 在直接监督下及诊断后诊疗中,医师助理执业安全有效。
- 医师助理与医师的患者满意度无差异。
- 证据不支持在未分化(诊断前)场景中对医师助理进行间接监督的安全性或有效性。
核心结论
- 本综述发现的证据有限,不支持在未分化(诊断前)场景中对医师助理进行间接监督的安全性或有效性。
- 关于医师助理监督和执业范围的国家指导可确保医师助理安全有效执业。
研究设计与样本
- 快速系统综述,关键词检索三个数据库,并对既往系统综述进行检索和引文追踪。
- 纳入标准为2005年1月至2025年1月发表的、在经济发达国家定量比较医师助理与医师(包括住院医师)所提供医疗的实证研究。
- 共筛选3636项研究,167项符合条件,40项符合纳入标准;纳入研究主要为弱质量的回顾性观察性研究。
- 大多数研究(31/40)来自美国,未发现新冠后背景下的数据。
- 两名评价员独立提取研究设计、样本、方法和发现的数据,每项研究使用偏倚风险工具评估;因异质性采用叙述性综合,并基于研究数量、质量和结果一致性评估证据信心。
主要发现
- 在直接监督下及诊断后诊疗中,医师助理执业安全有效的研究数量最多且结果最一致。
- 医师助理与医师之间的患者满意度无差异。
- 在医疗团队中加入医师助理增加了医疗可及性,但这可能反映的是人员增加带来的益处,而非医师助理角色的独特贡献。
- 成本效果方面的证据有限。
- 在英国,居住在社会经济贫困地区的患者更可能就诊于医师助理。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 纳入研究主要为弱质量的回顾性观察性研究。
- 大多数研究(31/40)来自美国,未发现新冠后背景下的数据。
- 因纳入研究异质性,采用叙述性综合而非定量合并。
- 成本效果方面的证据有限。
- 本综述发现的证据有限,不支持在未分化(诊断前)场景中对医师助理进行间接监督的安全性或有效性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine the impact of physician assistants, compared with physicians, on quality of care in the context of an ongoing UK policy review. DESIGN: Rapid systematic review. SEARCH STRATEGY: Keyword search of three databases; search and citation tracking of previous systematic reviews. ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA: Empirical studies that quantitatively compared care delivered by physician assistants with care delivered by physicians, including residents, in economically developed countries, published between January 2005 and January 2025. MAIN OUTCOMES OF INTEREST: Measures of outcomes of care, as defined by the Institute of Medicine's definition of quality: safety, effectiveness, patient centredness, timeliness, efficiency, and equity. METHODS: Eligible studies were categorised as primary care, secondary care, physician assistants versus residents in hospitals, diagnosis/performance, and cost effectiveness. Two reviewers independently extracted data on study design, samples, methods, and findings. Each study was assessed using a risk of bias tool. Owing to the heterogeneity of included studies, a narrative synthesis of the main findings was conducted. An assessment of confidence in the body of evidence for each outcome was based on the number and quality of relevant studies and the consistency of results between similar studies. RESULTS: Of 3636 studies screened, 167 studies were eligible and 40 met the inclusion criteria. These consisted mainly of retrospective observational studies of weak quality. Most (31/40) were from the US, and no data from a post-covid-19 context were found. The greatest number of studies with the most consistent results were those that found that physician assistants practised safely and effectively when working under direct supervision and in post-diagnostic care. No difference was found in patient satisfaction between physician assistants and physicians. Although adding physician assistants to medical teams increases access to care, this may reflect the benefits of increased staffing rather than the unique contribution of the physician assistant role. Evidence on cost effectiveness is limited. Patients in the UK are more likely to see a physician assistant if they live in a socioeconomically deprived area. CONCLUSION: The evidence found in this review is limited and does not support the safety or effectiveness of indirect supervision of physician assistants in undifferentiated (pre-diagnosis) settings. National guidance on the supervision and scope of practice for physician assistants can ensure that physician assistants practise safely and effectively. STUDY REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42024614992.
引用
- Cooper N, Agius S, Freeman K, et al. Impact of physician assistants on quality of care: rapid review. BMJ. 2025. PMID: 40610033. doi:10.1136/bmj-2025-086358
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。