针对公共卫生复杂干预的网络Meta分析的方法学综述及节点构建过程的类型学
该综述系统检索并纳入89篇综述和102个网络,描述网络Meta分析方法在公共卫生复杂干预中的应用,并基于主题网络分析构建了包含七类要素的节点构建类型学,以帮助未来网络设计并改进方法学步骤的报告。
要点
- 纳入89篇综述和102个网络,覆盖普遍性、选择性和指示性一级预防及身心健康结局。
- 几乎全部综述采用标准网络Meta分析模型,仅6篇报告了加性组分网络Meta分析模型。
- 节点构建方式包括分组相似干预或干预类型(65/102)、比较具名干预(6/102)、以干预组分组合定义节点(26/102)或使用组分分类分组(5/102)。
核心结论
- 网络Meta分析方法广泛应用于评估健康促进和一级预防中的复杂干预,所提出的节点构建要素类型学可为未来网络提供参考并促进方法学步骤的改进报告。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索并纳入应用于公共卫生(健康促进和一级预防)复杂干预的网络Meta分析应用研究,提取纳入综述和网络的特征及所用统计工具。
- 对纳入综述中与节点构建相关的文本摘录进行主题网络分析,以构建节点构建要素类型学。
主要发现
- 共纳入89篇综述和102个网络。
- 纳入综述覆盖广泛主题,包括普遍性、选择性和指示性一级预防,结局涉及身体健康和心理健康。
- 几乎全部综述应用标准网络Meta分析模型,仅6篇报告了加性组分网络Meta分析模型。
- 网络节点通过分组相似干预或干预类型形成(65/102),比较具名干预(6/102),以干预组分组合定义节点(26/102),或使用底层组分分类将干预分组为节点(5/102)。
- 构建了节点构建要素类型学,识别出七类潜在考虑因素(Approach、Ask、Aim、Appraise、Apply、Adapt和Assess)。
关键数值与推荐
- 节点构建方式:分组相似干预或干预类型65/102,比较具名干预6/102,以干预组分组合定义节点26/102,使用底层组分分类分组5/102。
- 标准网络Meta分析模型几乎全部应用,加性组分网络Meta分析模型仅6篇报告。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Network meta-analysis (NMA) methods allow simultaneous comparison of multiple interventions. Public health interventions are typically complex, being composed of multiple components. Methodological choices are therefore necessary when planning NMAs of complex interventions (eg, 'splitting' vs 'lumping'; intervention- vs component-level analysis). This node-making activity is often poorly reported and has received limited attention within methodological guidelines. This review aims to describe the use of NMA methods in this context and investigate the elements involved in node-making to develop a typology. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We conducted a systematic review to identify application of NMA methods to complex interventions applicable to public health (health promotion and primary prevention). We extracted the characteristics of the included reviews and networks, and the statistical tools applied therein. Thematic network analysis of text extracts related to node-making within the included reviews was applied to develop a typology of elements potentially involved in the formation of network nodes. RESULTS: We included 89 reviews and 102 networks applied to complex interventions relevant to public health. Included reviews were distributed across a breadth of topics including universal, selective, and indicated primary prevention, and involved outcomes including both physical and mental health. Almost all reviews applied standard NMA models, while just six reported additive component NMA models. Network nodes were formed by grouping similar interventions or intervention types (65/102), comparing named interventions (6/102), defining nodes as combinations of intervention components (26/102), or using an underlying component classification to group interventions into nodes (5/102). We developed a typology of node-making elements, identifying seven sets of potential considerations (Approach, Ask, Aim, Appraise, Apply, Adapt, and Assess). CONCLUSION: NMA methods are applied widely to evaluate complex interventions across health promotion and primary prevention. The proposed typology of these elements can inform future networks and facilitate improved reporting of methodological steps. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Public health interventions - such as programs to prevent smoking or increase physical activity - are often complex and made up of many parts ('components'). Deciding between multiple different interventions, or understanding which combination of intervention components works best, can require methods such as "network meta-analysis" (NMA). How to group interventions or components for NMA is known as 'node-making' but it is not clear what node-making approaches are currently used in NMA of public health interventions. In this paper, we reviewed 102 networks, identified from 89 reviews, and have summarized the range of methods used, with particular focus on the steps taken by reviewers to reach their node-making decisions. We arranged the identified node-making elements into seven categories, creating a classification which might be used to help researchers make decisions and report their methods in the future.
引用
- Davies TG, Halicka M, Melendez-Torres GJ, et al. A methodological review of network meta-analyses applied to complex interventions for public health and a typology of the node-making process. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 40451475. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.111856
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。