治疗层次结构的精确性:一种量化网络Meta分析中治疗层次结构确定性的指标
网络Meta分析(NMA)可估计多种竞争治疗的相对效应,常用SUCRA和P分数等排序指标生成治疗层次结构,但这些排序通常未报告确定性度量。作者提出新指标「治疗层次结构精确性(POTH)」,连接SUCRA方差、平均秩方差和个体秩分布平均方差,量化生成治疗层次结构的确定性,并展示其可适用于治疗子集(如前三位治疗),通过NMA数据库计算POTH以探讨其经验性质,并在两个已发表网络中进行演示。
要点
- SUCRA和P分数虽考虑不确定性,但由其产生的治疗层次结构通常未报告确定性度量,可能误导实践者。
- POTH连接SUCRA值方差、各治疗平均秩方差和个体秩分布平均方差,提供单一可解释的确定性量化值。
- POTH可适用于网络中的治疗子集,例如量化前三位治疗层次结构的确定性。
核心结论
- 作者提出POTH指标,可量化从SUCRA或P分数生成治疗层次结构的确定性,并提供单一可解释值。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学文章,提出新指标POTH,并在NMA数据库和两个已发表网络中进行演示。
主要发现
- POTH连接SUCRA值方差、各治疗平均秩方差和个体秩分布平均方差三个统计量。
- POTH可适用于治疗子集,例如量化前三位治疗层次结构的确定性。
- 作者在NMA数据库中计算POTH以探讨其经验性质,并在两个已发表网络中演示其用法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Network meta-analysis (NMA) is an extension of pairwise meta-analysis that facilitates the estimation of relative effects for multiple competing treatments. A hierarchy of treatments is a useful output of an NMA. Treatment hierarchies are produced using ranking metrics. Common ranking metrics include the Surface Under the Cumulative RAnking curve (SUCRA) and P-scores, which are the frequentist analogue to SUCRAs. Both metrics consider the size and uncertainty of the estimated treatment effects, with larger values indicating a more preferred treatment. Although SUCRAs and P-scores themselves consider uncertainty, treatment hierarchies produced by these ranking metrics are typically reported without a measure of certainty, which might be misleading to practitioners. We propose a new metric, Precision of Treatment Hierarchy (POTH), which quantifies the certainty in producing a treatment hierarchy from SUCRAs or P-scores. The metric connects three statistical quantities: The variance of the SUCRA values, the variance of the mean rank of each treatment, and the average variance of the distribution of individual ranks for each treatment. POTH provides a single, interpretable value that quantifies the extent of certainty in producing a treatment hierarchy. We show how the metric can be adapted to apply to subsets of treatments in a network, for example, to quantify the certainty in the hierarchy of the top three treatments. We calculate POTH for a database of NMAs to investigate its empirical properties, and we demonstrate its use on two published networks.
引用
- Wigle A, Béliveau A, Salanti G, et al. Precision of Treatment Hierarchy: A Metric for Quantifying Certainty in Treatment Hierarchies From Network Meta-Analysis. Stat Med. 2025. PMID: 40542622. doi:10.1002/sim.70176
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。