系统评价作者使用GRADE方法的经验与挑战:一项定性研究
该定性研究通过半结构化访谈和经验问卷,调查了具有系统评价方法学和GRADE使用经验的主要研究者对GRADE方法的反馈及实施障碍。41名受邀专家中11人参与,参与者认可GRADE结构化评估证据的价值,但指出其复杂性、分级主观性以及需要更多实用指导和示例。使用障碍包括应用特定领域(主要是不精确性和间接性)困难、缺乏充分培训、时间限制、动机和态度障碍以及经费限制。
要点
- 参与者认可GRADE结构化评估证据的方法,但指出其复杂性、分级主观性和需要更多实用指导与示例。
- 使用障碍包括应用特定领域(主要是不精确性和间接性)困难、缺乏充分培训、时间限制、动机和态度障碍以及经费限制。
- 参与者强调正规教育、改进指南和期刊更多支持对促进GRADE采用的重要性,并对GRADE是否应在所有系统评价中强制使用持混合意见。
核心结论
- 为增强GRADE的使用,研究界应侧重于改进培训、开发更高效的工具,并在标准化与科学灵活性之间取得平衡。
研究设计与样本
- 采用半结构化访谈的定性研究,访谈对象为在系统评价方法学和GRADE使用方面经验丰富的主要研究者,访谈前所有参与者完成关于GRADE使用经验和系统评价实施的结构化问卷。
- 41名受邀专家中11人参与研究。
主要发现
- 参与者认可GRADE结构化评估证据的方法,但指出若干挑战,包括其复杂性、分级中的感知主观性以及需要更多实用指导和示例。
- GRADE使用的障碍包括应用特定领域(主要是不精确性和间接性)困难、缺乏充分培训、时间限制、动机和态度障碍以及经费限制。
- 参与者强调正规教育、改进指南和期刊更多支持对鼓励GRADE采用的重要性。
- 参与者对GRADE是否应在所有系统评价中强制使用持混合意见;虽然同意需要推广GRADE,但对普遍实施可能阻碍研究灵活性和创新表示担忧。
局限性
- 41名受邀专家中仅11人参与研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to gather feedback from systematic review authors on the use of the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluations (GRADE) approach and to explore potential barriers to its implementation. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A qualitative study was conducted using semistructured interviews with principal investigators who are experienced in systematic review methodology and the use of the GRADE approach, about their experiences and challenges in using GRADE. Before the interview, all participants completed a structured questionnaire about their experience with GRADE and in conducting systematic reviews. RESULTS: Eleven of 41 invited experts participated in the study, offering detailed insights into the experiences and challenges of using GRADE. While the participants appreciated GRADE's structured approach to evaluating evidence, they highlighted several challenges, including its complexity, perceived subjectivity in grading, and the need for more practical guidance and examples. Barriers to GRADE use included difficulties in applying specific domains (primarily imprecision and indirectness), lack of adequate training, time constraints, motivational and attitudinal barriers, and financial limitations. The participants emphasized the importance of formal education, improved guidelines, and greater journal support to encourage GRADE adoption. They expressed mixed opinions on whether GRADE should be mandatory in all systematic reviews. While participants agreed on the need to promote GRADE, concerns were raised about its universal implementation potentially hindering research flexibility and innovation. CONCLUSION: To enhance the use of GRADE, the research community should focus on improving training, developing more efficient tools, and striking a balance between standardization and scientific flexibility. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: GRADE is a tool to check how reliable and good the evidence is in research. This study looked at the challenges researchers face when using GRADE and their opinions on improving it. Researchers found GRADE valuable because it is well structured but noted it has issues such as being too complex, subjective, and needing clearer instructions. Other problems were the lack of training, not enough time and money, and low motivation. Researchers said that better training, clearer guidelines, and support from journals are needed to make GRADE easier to use.
引用
- Andrić A, Poklepović Peričić T, Tokalić R, et al. Experiences and challenges faced by systematic review authors in using the GRADE approach: a qualitative study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 40545183. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.111870
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。