CLIMATRIAL:一种量化南非临床试验碳足迹新方法的适用性与可适应性
该研究评估英国国家卫生研究院(NIHR)临床试验排放追踪方法在南非的适用性与可适应性。研究选取一项大型整群随机试验为范例,于2023年12月至2024年3月开展,量化纸张使用与打印、现场差旅和电力消耗的排放,发现南非排放因子远高于英国,且本地公开排放因子缺乏。结论认为NIHR指南经小幅修改后适用于南非,但排放结果应视为指示性。
要点
- NIHR方法经小幅修改后适用于南非临床试验碳足迹评估。
- 纸张使用与打印排放2274.88 kgCO2e,现场差旅约80,000 km排放17,891 kgCO2e。
- 电力消耗排放12,515 kgCO2e,南非排放因子远高于英国。
核心结论
- NIHR指南经小幅修改后适用于南非背景,是高度可适应的框架,但缺乏本地排放因子降低准确性,排放结果应视为指示性。
研究设计与样本
- 采用应用与实施方法,建立正式利益相关方结构,选取一项在城乡多站点开展的大型整群随机卫生服务提供干预试验作为范例,测试NIHR方法。
- 创建包含十个推荐活动阶段的试验流程图和Excel工作簿,优先计算纸张使用与打印、站点间本地差旅、试验总部与站点电力消耗,活动数据从组织财务工具中提取。
- 研究于2023年12月至2024年3月进行。
主要发现
- 纸张使用与打印活动在试验设置和干预实施期间发生,排放2274.88 kgCO2e。
- 现场工作人员在干预实施和随访期间站点间差旅约80,000 km(2016年至2019年),排放17,891 kgCO2e。
- 电力消耗基于全职等效人员计算,4年期间排放12,515 kgCO2e。
- 观察到英国与南非可用排放因子之间存在巨大差异,南非排放因子远高于英国。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 缺乏公开可用的本地排放因子来源,降低准确性,排放结果应视为指示性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: No formal assessment of a method to measure the carbon emissions from a clinical trial has been undertaken in the low- and middle-income country setting. We aimed to evaluate the UK-based National Institute of Health Research (NIHR) method for tracking trial emissions for applicability and adaptability to the South African context. Objectives included to (1) identify gaps in trial activity data, (2) locate local emission factor sources, (3) quantify emissions and (4) investigate modifications required to ensure the method was locally applicable. METHOD: We adopted an application and implementation approach. We established a formal stakeholder structure focused on sustainable clinical trials to guide and support our approach. We selected a large cluster-randomised trial of a health service delivery intervention conducted across multiple urban and rural sites as an exemplar typical of local conditions to test the NIHR method. We created a trial process map outlining ten recommended activity stages for carbon emissions and an Excel workbook to calculate emissions for each stage. We prioritised calculations of those activities for which we had the most complete data: paper usage and printing, local travel between sites, and electricity consumption at the trial head office and at trial sites. We extracted activity data from organisational financial instruments. RESULTS: The study took place between December 2023 and March 2024. We identified a lack of publicly available local emission factor sources. Paper usage and printing activities took place at trial set-up and during intervention delivery and emitted 2274.88 kgCO2e. Field staff travel between trial sites during intervention delivery and follow-up resulted in approximately 80,000 km travelled between 2016 and 2019 contributing 17,891 kgCO2e. Electricity consumption was based on full-time equivalent staff and yielded 12,515 kgCO2e during the 4-year period. We observed large differences between UK and available SA emission factors with SA emission factors far higher than those in the UK. CONCLUSION: We found that with minor modifications, the NIHR guidance is applicable to the SA context. It is a highly adaptable framework permitting tracking of activities across trial stages. A lack of locally available emission factors reduces accuracy and emission results should be viewed as indicative.
引用
- Siegfried NL, Erasmus-Claassen LA, Griffiths J, et al. CLIMATRIAL: applicability and adaptability of a novel method to quantify the carbon footprint of a South African clinical trial. Trials. 2025. PMID: 40533806. doi:10.1186/s13063-025-08903-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。