指南与共识医学教育与科研方法

活指南推荐意见不会「反复摇摆」:考察活指南中推荐意见方向改变的概率

Living recommendations do not "flip-flop": examining the probability of directional changes to recommendations in living guidelines.
指南 / 共识 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2025-06-21

该研究对新冠、卒中和炎性关节炎三部活指南的所有推荐更新进行量化与特征分析,共识别241次更新、累计13年,其中26次推荐方向改变,但无任何推荐出现两次方向改变(即「反复摇摆」)。作者认为活指南推荐方向改变不常见,反复摇摆可能罕见,指南使用者可对当前决策的稳定性抱有信心。

要点

  • 三部活指南累计13年共发生241次推荐更新,多数未影响推荐强度或方向。
  • 共26次推荐方向改变,但无任何推荐出现两次方向改变(反复摇摆)。
  • 作者认为推荐反复摇摆可能罕见,使用者可对当前决策的稳定性抱有信心。

核心结论

  • 活指南推荐确实会改变方向,但当前分析提示这种情况不常见,推荐反复摇摆可能罕见。
  • 指南使用者可以确信,他们今天做出的决策不会因活指南更新而突然改变。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究对三部示例性活指南(分别聚焦COVID-19、卒中和炎性关节炎)的所有活推荐更新进行量化与特征描述。
  • 收集推荐意见、更新日期及纳入研究和参与者总数等信息,并按对推荐的影响对变化进行分类,重点关注推荐方向的变化。

主要发现

  • 三部指南在累计13年期间共发生241次个体更新,其中多数未影响推荐强度或方向。
  • 共有26次推荐方向改变,但没有任何推荐出现两次方向改变,即未发生反复摇摆。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Living approaches to guideline development enable the maintenance of up-to-date recommendations, ensuring that users are basing health care decisions on the best available evidence. At present, the stability of living recommendations across multiple updates is yet to be established, and there is a risk that the direction of recommendations may change following the frequent inclusion of new evidence. The objective of this article is to examine the probability of living recommendations changing direction multiple times (ie, flip-flopping) following identification and inclusion of new relevant information. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: All updates to living recommendations across three exemplar living guidelines focused on COVID-19, stroke, and inflammatory arthritis, were quantified and characterized. Information regarding the recommendation, date of update, and total number of studies and participants included was captured. Changes were classified based on impact on the recommendation, with a particular focus on changes in the direction of recommendations. RESULTS: There were a total of 241 individual updates across all three guidelines over a period of 13 cumulative years, the majority of which did not affect the strength or direction of recommendation. Although there were 26 instances in which a recommendation changed direction, there were no instances in which a recommendation changed direction twice, in other words, flip-flopped. CONCLUSION: Although living recommendations do change direction, the current analysis suggests that this happens infrequently and instances of recommendations flip-flopping are likely rare. Guideline users can be confident that the decisions they make today would not suddenly change following updates to living recommendations.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. White H, Synnot A, Glennon V, et al. Living recommendations do not "flip-flop": examining the probability of directional changes to recommendations in living guidelines. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 40550403. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.111874

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。