指南与共识医学教育与科研方法流行病学与生物统计

何为优质指南?——基于AGREE II工具对老年骨科及相关领域120部临床实践指南的系统评价与分析

"What makes a good guideline? - A systematic review and analysis of 120 clinical practice guidelines in orthogeriatric care and related fields using the AGREE II tool".
指南 / 共识 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2025-05-13

该研究检索Medline及8个指南数据库,纳入2016年1月1日起以英文或德文发表、适用于急性骨科/创伤外科老年患者(≥60岁、衰弱或痴呆/谵妄)且采用证据评价的临床实践指南,由三名不同专业背景评价者用AGREE II工具评价120部指南。平均总体评分为4.35(±1.13),使用标准化证据评级框架与更好的总体评分显著相关(P < .001)。多变量分析显示条目9、12、15对总体AGREE II评分影响最大,领域6(编辑独立性)在多变量分析中不影响总体评分。

要点

  • 共评价120部指南,平均总体评分为4.35(±1.13)。
  • 使用标准化证据评级框架与更好的总体评分显著相关(P < .001)。
  • 多变量分析中条目9、12、15对总体AGREE II评分影响最大。

核心结论

  • 方法学严谨性,尤其是使用标准化证据评级框架,对获得良好的AGREE II总体评分及高质量临床实践指南至关重要。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统评价与分析,检索Medline及8个指南数据库,纳入2016年1月1日起以英文或德文发表、适用于急性骨科/创伤外科老年患者(≥60岁、衰弱或痴呆/谵妄)且采用证据评价的临床实践指南,最终评价120部指南。

主要发现

  • 120部指南的平均总体评分为4.35(±1.13)。
  • 大多数指南总体评分为5分(n = 40,33.33%),1部指南总体评分为1分(0.8%)。
  • 使用标准化证据评级框架(如GRADE)与更好的总体评分显著相关(P < .001)。
  • 多变量分析显示条目9、12、15对总体AGREE II评分影响最大。
  • 领域6(编辑独立性)在多变量分析中不影响总体评分。

关键数值与推荐

  • 使用AGREE II工具全部6个领域23个条目进行评价,由三名不同专业背景的评价者完成。
  • 使用标准化证据评级框架与更好的总体评分显著相关(P < .001)。
  • 多变量分析中条目9、12、15对总体AGREE II评分影响最大。
  • 领域6(编辑独立性)在多变量分析中不影响总体评分。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) translate evidence into actionable recommendations to enhance care quality, improve clinical outcomes, reduce treatment variations, and make health-care delivery more cost-effective. CPGs primarily aid health-care practitioners but are also used by patients, policymakers, and organizations. The study aim was to assess CPG quality using the Appraisal of Guidelines, Research and Evaluation (AGREE) II instrument and to identify AGREE II items and domains that influence the overall assessment. METHODS: Medline and eight CPG databases were searched for guidelines applicable to older patients (≥60 years, frail, or with dementia/delirium) in acute orthopedic/traumatological settings, published in English or German since January 1, 2016, and using an evidence appraisal. Titles, abstracts, and full texts were independently screened by two reviewers using Covidence. AGREE II assessments were conducted across all 23 items in six domains by three reviewers with different professional backgrounds. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics, Mann-Whitney U test, Pearson's r correlation matrix, variance inflation factor, univariable and multivariable regression (nonnegative least squares), and intraclass correlation coefficient. Significance was set at P < .05. RESULTS: A total of 120 CPGs have been appraised, reaching a mean overall rating of 4.35 (±1.13). Most guidelines received an overall rating of five (n = 40, 33.33%), one guideline received an overall rating of one (0.8%). Using a standardized evidence rating framework (eg, Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation) is significantly associated with a better overall rating (P < .001). The multivariable analysis showed that items 9, 12, and 15 had the highest influence on the overall AGREE II rating. Domain 6 (editorial independence) did not have an influence on the overall rating in a multivariable analysis. CONCLUSION: Methodological rigor, particularly the use of a standardized evidence rating framework, is essential for a good overall AGREE II rating and thus for high-quality CPGs. The results from this analysis can assist different stakeholders who also conduct AGREE II appraisals, develop CPGs, or are charged with implementing CPG recommendations.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Fotteler ML, Kocar TD, Willems J, et al. "What makes a good guideline? - A systematic review and analysis of 120 clinical practice guidelines in orthogeriatric care and related fields using the AGREE II tool". J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 40374018. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.111830

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。