指南与共识医学教育与科研方法

活指南制定方法:论文6:澳大利亚活证据协作组织(ALEC)在活指南制定中使用现有系统综述的经验与建议

Methods for living guidelines: paper 6: insights from Australian Living Evidence Collaboration's (ALEC) use of existing systematic reviews in living guideline development.
指南 / 共识 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2025-05-05

本文基于对澳大利亚活证据协作组织(ALEC)成员的访谈,提出在制定活指南(尤其是首版)时评估已发表系统综述适用性的建议。适用综述应具备相关范围、透明报告和恰当检索方法;理想情况下还应较新、对纳入研究进行批判性评价并清晰呈现研究水平数据。若未满足这些条件,指南制定者可能需要额外工作来弥补。

要点

  • 使用现有系统综述前需评估其适用性与质量,相关范围、透明报告和恰当检索方法是基本条件。
  • 理想综述还应较新、对纳入研究进行批判性评价并清晰呈现研究水平数据。
  • 若综述未满足上述条件,指南制定者可能需要额外工作来弥补其局限性。

核心结论

  • 现有系统综述有潜力减少活指南证据基础整理的工作量,但其最佳使用存在障碍,指南制定者应全面评估综述的适用性。

研究设计与样本

  • 对澳大利亚活证据协作组织(ALEC)成员进行访谈,综合访谈数据形成在活指南制定中使用已发表系统综述的建议,并识别实例。

主要发现

  • 适用综述应具有相关范围、透明报告和恰当检索方法;若未满足这些标准,综述 unlikely 有价值。
  • 理想情况下综述还应较新、对纳入研究进行批判性评价并清晰呈现研究水平数据;若未做到,指南制定者可能需要额外工作来弥补这些局限。

关键数值与推荐

  • 评估已发表系统综述适用性的标准包括:相关范围、透明报告、恰当检索方法;理想情况下还应较新、对纳入研究进行批判性评价并清晰呈现研究水平数据。

临床怎么用

  • 指南制定者在使用现有系统综述前应全面评估其适用性;若综述未满足基本标准,则其 unlikely 对活指南有价值。
  • 若综述未进行批判性评价或未清晰呈现研究水平数据,指南制定者可能需要额外工作来弥补这些局限。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Using published peer-reviewed systematic reviews are in theory an efficient way of establishing the evidence base for a guideline, however barriers to their optimal use exist. This article presents suggestions for assessing a published systematic reviews and determining its capacity to act as the evidence base primarily for the first version of a living guideline. Practical examples, based on the experiences of the Australian Living Evidence Collaboration (ALEC), are provided. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Members of ALEC were interviewed regarding their approach to using published systematic reviews when developing a living guideline. Interview data were synthesized and used to formulate suggestions for using published systematic reviews in the development of a living guideline and examples were identified. RESULTS: Before using an existing systematic review for a living guideline, developers need to consider the suitability and quality of the review. Suitable reviews should have a relevant scope, transparent reporting, and appropriate search methods. Without these criteria being met, the review is unlikely to be of value. Ideally the review should also be recent, have critically appraised the included studies, and clearly present study level data. Where this has not been done, guideline developers may need to undertake additional work to remedy these limitations. CONCLUSION: While existing systematic reviews have the potential to reduce the workload associated with collating the evidence base for a living guideline, barriers exist to their optimal use. Guideline developers should thoroughly assess the review for its suitability. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Clinical practice guidelines should be based on the best available evidence, and living guidelines should stay up to date as new studies are published. Undertaking a review of all the studies related to a guideline topic is a lot of work. Using an existing review of the literature, that has already been published, can help reduce this workload. We conducted interviews with experienced guideline developers to see how they use existing evidence reviews to make their living guidelines. Based on these interviews, we suggest how to best use an existing review to create a living guideline. This includes locating an appropriate review with a relevant scope, checking for clear reporting, and if the right studies were included. If a review does not meet these appropriate criteria, it is unlikely to be of value to form a living guideline. Ideally the review should also be recent, have considered the quality of the included studies, and clearly present the results of each study it included. If this has not been done, guideline developers may need to undertake additional work to use the review.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. St Pierre K, Cashmore B, Cumpston MS, et al. Methods for living guidelines: paper 6: insights from Australian Living Evidence Collaboration's (ALEC) use of existing systematic reviews in living guideline development. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 40334719. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.111812

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。