文献速递临床试验与 GCP流行病学与生物统计

基于X线的膝骨关节炎诊断与解释对患者管理信念的影响:一项随机临床试验

Effects of X-ray-based diagnosis and explanation of knee osteoarthritis on patient beliefs about osteoarthritis management: A randomised clinical trial.
PubMed 文献 · PLoS Med · 2025-02-04

该三臂随机对照试验于2024年5月23日至28日通过在线调查纳入617名≥45岁澳大利亚社区人群,比较临床解释与影像学解释及是否展示X线图像对患者信念的影响。结果显示,与临床解释相比,接受影像学解释并展示X线图像者认为手术必要性更高(均值3.3 vs 4.5,均差1.1,95%CI 0.5–1.8),但运动帮助性信念无差异;是否展示图像对信念无差异。作者认为基于X线的诊断与解释可能对管理信念产生潜在不良影响。

要点

  • 与临床解释相比,影像学解释并展示X线图像使患者认为关节置换手术必要性更高(均差1.1,95%CI 0.5–1.8)。
  • 两种解释方式对运动与体力活动帮助性的信念无差异(均差-0.4,95%CI -0.9–0.1)。
  • 影像学解释中是否展示X线图像对手术必要性和运动帮助性信念均无差异。

核心结论

  • 基于X线的膝骨关节炎诊断与解释可能对患者的管理信念产生潜在不良影响。

研究设计与样本

  • 三臂随机对照试验,于2024年5月23日至2024年5月28日通过单次暴露(无随访)的在线调查进行。
  • 从澳大利亚全国社区招募617名年龄≥45岁、伴或不伴慢性膝痛的人群。
  • 参与者被随机分配观看全科医生提供的2分钟视频:临床解释(无X线)、影像学解释(不展示X线图像)或影像学解释(展示X线图像)。

主要发现

  • 与临床解释(无X线)相比,接受影像学解释(展示X线图像)者认为手术更必要(均值3.3[标准差2.7] vs 4.5[2.7],均差1.1[Bonferroni校正95%CI 0.5, 1.8])。
  • 与临床解释(无X线)相比,影像学解释(展示X线图像)对运动与体力活动帮助性的信念无差异(均值7.9[标准差1.9] vs 7.5[2.2],均差-0.4[Bonferroni校正95%CI -0.9, 0.1])。
  • 影像学解释展示与不展示X线图像对手术必要性信念无差异(均值4.5[标准差2.7] vs 3.9[2.6],均差0.5[Bonferroni校正95%CI -0.1, 1.2])。
  • 影像学解释展示与不展示X线图像对运动与体力活动帮助性信念无差异(均值7.5[标准差2.2] vs 7.7[2.0],均差-0.2[Bonferroni校正95%CI -0.7, 0.3])。

局限性

  • 参与者是对假设情景做出反应,因此研究结果可能不一定能转化到真实临床情境。
  • 尚不清楚这些效应是否会影响后续的骨关节炎管理行为。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Although X-rays are not recommended for routine diagnosis of osteoarthritis (OA), clinicians and patients often use or expect X-rays. We evaluated whether: (i) a radiographic diagnosis and explanation of knee OA influences patient beliefs about management, compared to a clinical diagnosis and explanation that does not involve X-rays; and (ii) showing the patient their X-ray images when explaining radiographic report findings influences beliefs, compared to not showing X-ray images. METHODS AND FINDINGS: This was a 3-arm randomised controlled trial conducted between May 23, 2024 and May 28, 2024 as a single exposure (no follow-up) online survey. A total of 617 people aged ≥45 years, with and without chronic knee pain, were recruited from the Australian-wide community. Participants were presented with a hypothetical scenario where their knee was painful for 6 months and they had made an appointment with a general practitioner (primary care physician). Participants were randomly allocated to one of 3 groups where they watched a 2-min video of the general practitioner providing them with either: (i) clinical explanation of knee OA (no X-rays); (ii) radiographic explanation (not showing X-ray images); or (iii) radiographic explanation (showing X-ray images). Primary comparisons were: (i) clinical explanation (no X-rays) versus radiographic explanation (showing X-ray images); and (ii) radiographic explanation (not showing X-ray images) versus radiographic explanation (showing X-ray images). Primary outcomes were perceived (i) necessity of joint replacement surgery; and (ii) helpfulness of exercise and physical activity, both measured on 11-point numeric rating scales (NRS) ranging 0 to 10. Compared to clinical explanation (no X-rays), those who received radiographic explanation (showing X-ray images) believed surgery was more necessary (mean 3.3 [standard deviation: 2.7] versus 4.5 [2.7], respectively; mean difference 1.1 [Bonferroni-adjusted 95% confidence interval: 0.5, 1.8]), but there were no differences in beliefs about the helpfulness of exercise and physical activity (mean 7.9 [standard deviation: 1.9] versus 7.5 [2.2], respectively; mean difference -0.4 [Bonferroni-adjusted 95% confidence interval: -0.9, 0.1]). There were no differences in beliefs between radiographic explanation with and without showing X-ray images (for beliefs about necessity of surgery: mean 4.5 [standard deviation: 2.7] versus 3.9 [2.6], respectively; mean difference 0.5 [Bonferroni-adjusted 95% confidence interval: -0.1, 1.2]; for beliefs about helpfulness of exercise and physical activity: mean 7.5 [standard deviation: 2.2] versus 7.7 [2.0], respectively; mean difference -0.2 [Bonferroni-adjusted 95% confidence interval: -0.7, 0.3]). Limitations of our study included the fact that participants were responding to a hypothetical scenario, and so findings may not necessarily translate to real-world clinical situations, and that it is unclear whether effects would impact subsequent OA management behaviours. CONCLUSIONS: An X-ray-based diagnosis and explanation of knee OA may have potentially undesirable effects on people's beliefs about management. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ACTRN12624000622505.

来源:PLoS Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lawford BJ, Bennell KL, Ewald D, et al. Effects of X-ray-based diagnosis and explanation of knee osteoarthritis on patient beliefs about osteoarthritis management: A randomised clinical trial. PLoS Med. 2025. PMID: 39903790. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1004537

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。