PubMed Central 文章中试验注册号在全文的分布:对关联试验与发表及索引发表类型的意义
该研究扫描 PubMed Central 开放获取全文数据集中提及 ClinicalTrials.gov 及国际临床试验注册号的文章,分析注册号在文章各章节的分布及其与发表类型索引的关系。结果显示,元数据或方法部分提及注册号对识别临床试验文章高度预测,仅方法部分提及 NCT 号时均报告该注册试验的临床结局,而表格中注册号几乎全部来自综述;提及 CONSORT 或 SPIRIT 的临床试验文章更常在元数据中提及注册号。
要点
- 元数据或方法部分提及注册号对识别临床试验文章高度预测。
- 仅方法部分提及 NCT 号的临床试验文章均报告该注册试验的临床结局。
- 表格中注册号几乎全部来自综述(含系统综述和 Meta 分析)。
核心结论
- 试验注册号在生物医学文章全文中的出现位置为关联临床试验与发表提供有价值的特征,也可能辅助自动化工具分配发表类型。
研究设计与样本
- 研究扫描 PubMed Central 全文开放获取数据集中提及 ClinicalTrials.gov 和国际临床试验注册号的文章,分析注册号在各章节的分布,并描述其发表类型索引及其他指标。
主要发现
- 文章元数据(如摘要)或全文方法部分提及的注册号对临床试验文章高度预测。
- 临床试验文章仅在方法部分提及 ClinicalTrials.gov 标识号(NCT)时,所检查的每例均报告该注册试验的临床结局,可可靠用于关联该试验与该发表。
- 表格中提及的注册号几乎全部来自综述(包括系统综述和 Meta 分析)。
- 其他全文章节提及的注册号对关联试验与发表预测价值相对较小。
- 提及 CONSORT 或 SPIRIT 指南的临床试验文章在文章元数据中提及注册号的比例高于整体文章,因而更易与其 underlying 试验关联。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Linking registered clinical trials with their published results continues to be a challenge. A variety of natural language processing (NLP)-based and machine learning-based models have been developed to assist users in identifying these connections. To date, however, no system has attempted to detect mentions of registry numbers within the full-text of articles. METHODS: Articles from the PubMed Central full-text Open Access dataset were scanned for mentions of ClinicalTrials.gov and international clinical trial registry identifiers. We analyzed the distribution of trial registry numbers within sections of the articles and characterized their publication type indexing and other metrics. RESULTS: Registry numbers mentioned in article metadata (e.g., the abstract) or in the Methods section of full-text are highly predictive of clinical trial articles. When a clinical trial article mentioned ClinicalTrials.gov identifier numbers (NCT) only in the Methods section, in every case examined, it was reporting clinical outcomes from that registered trial, and thus can reliably be used to link that trial to that publication. Conversely, registry numbers mentioned in Tables arise almost entirely from reviews (including systematic reviews and meta-analyses). Registry numbers mentioned in other full-text sections have relatively little predictive value for linking trials to their publications. Clinical trial articles that mention CONSORT or SPIRIT guidelines have a higher rate of mentioning registry numbers in article metadata, and hence are more easily linked to their underlying trials, than articles overall. CONCLUSIONS: The appearance and location of trial registry numbers within the full-text of biomedical articles provide valuable features for connecting clinical trials to their publications. They also potentially provide information to assist automated tools in assigning publication types to articles.
引用
- Holt AM, Troy AM, Smalheiser NR, et al. Distribution of trial registry numbers within full-text of PubMed Central articles: implications for linking trials to publications and indexing trial publication types. Trials. 2025. PMID: 39891272. doi:10.1186/s13063-025-08741-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。