影像申请临床决策支持系统评估:一项整群随机临床试验
在德国3所大学医院的26个科室开展整群随机临床试验,评估欧洲放射学会iGuide临床决策支持系统(CDSS)对医生影像申请适当性的影响。共65 764例影像申请被评分,干预组与对照组在不适当影像申请比例变化上的双重差分值为1.3个百分点(99%CI,-2.0至1.8个百分点;P=0.69),无统计学显著差异。结论认为CDSS未减少学术医院环境中医生开具的不适当影像申请。
要点
- 在26个科室的整群随机试验中,CDSS未显著减少不适当影像申请。
- 干预组不适当申请比例平均变化-0.5%(99%CI,-2.4%至0.4%),对照组-1.8%(99%CI,-4.3%至-0.4%)。
- 双重差分值1.3个百分点(99%CI,-2.0至1.8个百分点;P=0.69),未达统计学显著。
核心结论
- CDSS未减少学术医院环境中医生开具的不适当影像申请数量。
研究设计与样本
- 整群随机临床试验,采用前后对照的中断设计,以德国3所大学医院的26个科室为整群。
- 纳入参与科室医生在2021年12月至2024年6月共2.5年期间提出的所有影像申请。
- 所有科室初始均无CDSS并需结构化录入临床适应证数据及追踪申请影像;随机化后13个整群接受CDSS干预,13个整群为对照。
主要发现
- 共65 764例影像申请经CDSS评分;50.1%的申请为女性患者,患者平均年龄64岁(SD,17.1岁)。
- CDSS实施前,对照整群有21 625例影像申请,其中1367例(6.3%)被归类为不适当;干预整群有13 338例申请,其中1007例(7.6%)被归类为不适当。
- CDSS实施后,对照整群有10 055例申请,其中518例(5.2%)被归类为不适当;干预整群有7206例申请,其中461例(6.4%)被归类为不适当。
- 干预整群不适当影像申请平均变化-0.5%(99%CI,-2.4%至0.4%),对照整群平均变化-1.8%(99%CI,-4.3%至-0.4%),双重差分值1.3个百分点(99%CI,-2.0至1.8个百分点;P=0.69),无统计学显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- CDSS向开具申请的医生提供信息:影像申请属于适当、特定条件下适当或不适当,并建议替代诊断检查及相应适当性评分,之后医生可选择修改影像申请。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Given the widespread use of medical imaging, evaluating the effectiveness of interventions to improve appropriateness is crucial for optimizing health care resources and patient outcomes. OBJECTIVE: To assess the effects of implementing a clinical decision support system (CDSS), the European Society of Radiology iGuide, on the appropriateness of the medical imaging ordering behavior of physicians. DESIGN AND SETTING: A cluster randomized clinical trial with 26 departments at 3 German university hospitals acting as clusters, incorporating a before and after discontinued design. All imaging requests originating from physicians in the participating departments over a 2.5-year period were included (between December 2021 and June 2024). INTERVENTIONS: All departments started without a CDSS and required structured clinical indication data entry and tracking of requested imaging. After randomization, 13 clusters (departments at hospitals) received the CDSS intervention (intervention clusters) and 13 clusters did not (control clusters). The CDSS intervention provided ordering physicians with information as to whether their imaging requests were appropriate, appropriate under certain conditions, or inappropriate; in addition, alternative diagnostic tests, including the corresponding appropriateness score, were suggested by the CDSS, after which physicians could choose to modify their imaging requests. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The primary outcome measure was the proportion of inappropriate imaging requests made per department. A difference-in-differences analysis was used to investigate changes in the proportion of inappropriate imaging requests between departments with vs those without the CDSS. RESULTS: A total of 65 764 imaging requests were scored using the CDSS; 50.1% of imaging requests were for female patients and the mean patient age was 64 years (SD, 17.1 years). Prior to implementation of the CDSS, there were 21 625 imaging requests from the control clusters, 1367 (6.3%) of which were categorized as inappropriate; and there were 13 338 imaging requests from the intervention clusters, 1007 (7.6%) of which were categorized as inappropriate. After implementation of the CDSS, there were 10 055 imaging requests from the control clusters, 518 (5.2%) of which were categorized as inappropriate; and there were 7206 imaging requests from the intervention clusters, 461 (6.4%) of which were categorized as inappropriate. The intervention clusters showed a similar reduction (mean difference, -0.5% [99% CI, -2.4% to 0.4%]) in inappropriate imaging requests compared with the control clusters (mean difference, -1.8% [99% CI, -4.3% to -0.4%]) and there was a difference-in-differences value of 1.3 percentage points (99% CI, -2.0 to 1.8 percentage points; P = .69), which was not statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: The CDSS did not reduce the number of inappropriate imaging requests ordered by physicians in academic hospital settings. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT05490290.
引用
- Dijk SW, Wollny C, Barkhausen J, et al. Evaluation of a Clinical Decision Support System for Imaging Requests: A Cluster Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA. 2025. PMID: 39928308. doi:10.1001/jama.2024.27853
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。