随机对照试验中相对风险与风险差的估计:当前实践的系统综述
该系统综述纳入2018年1月1日至2023年3月11日发表于JAMA、NEJM、Lancet或BMJ的双臂平行随机对照试验,共308项,其中49%(95%CI:43-54%)报告了协变量校正的相对风险或风险差;报告校正相对风险的研究常用对数二项模型(65%)和改良Poisson模型(29%),报告校正风险差的研究常用二项模型(48%)和边际标准化(21%);许多试验缺乏估计方法的充分细节。
要点
- 约半数随机对照试验报告了协变量校正的相对风险或风险差。
- 校正相对风险最常用对数二项模型和改良Poisson模型。
- 校正风险差最常用二项模型和边际标准化。
核心结论
- 约半数随机对照试验报告协变量校正的相对风险或风险差,许多试验缺乏估计方法的充分细节。
- 在报告方法的研究中,二项模型、改良Poisson模型及较少使用的边际标准化是常用方法。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述纳入2018年1月1日至2023年3月11日发表于JAMA、NEJM、Lancet或BMJ的双臂平行随机对照试验,共308项。
- 检索在Ovid-MEDLINE进行。
主要发现
- 308项随机对照试验中,49%(95%CI:43-54%)报告了协变量校正的相对风险或风险差。
- 报告校正相对风险的研究中,报告清晰者(n=65,79%)最常用对数二项模型(65%的研究使用;95%CI:52-76%)和改良Poisson模型(29%;95%CI:19-42%)。
- 报告校正风险差的研究中,报告清晰者(n=56,61%)常用二项模型(48%的研究使用;95%CI:35-62%)和边际标准化(21%;95%CI:12-35%)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Guidelines for randomised controlled trials (RCTs) recommend reporting relative and absolute measures of effect for binary outcomes while adjusting for covariates. There are a number of different ways covariate-adjusted relative risks and risk differences can be estimated. OBJECTIVES: Our goal was to identify methods used to estimate covariate-adjusted relative risk and risk differences in RCTs published in high-impact journals with binary outcomes. Other secondary objectives included the identification of how covariates are chosen for adjustment and whether covariate adjustment results in an increase in statistical precision in practice. METHODS: We included two-arm parallel RCTs published in JAMA, NEJM, Lancet, or the BMJ between January 1, 2018, and March 11, 2023, reporting relative risks or risk differences as a summary measure for a binary primary outcome. The search was conducted in Ovid-MEDLINE. RESULTS: Of the 308 RCTs identified, around half (49%; 95% CI: 43-54%) reported a covariate-adjusted relative risk or risk difference. Of these, 82 reported an adjusted relative risk. When the reporting was clear (n = 65, 79%), the log-binomial model (used in 65% of studies; 95% CI: 52-76%) and modified Poisson (29%; 95% CI: 19-42%) were most commonly used. Of the 92 studies that reported an adjusted risk difference, when the reporting was clear (n = 56, 61%), the binomial model (used in 48% of studies; 95% CI: 35-62%) and marginal standardisation (21%; 95% CI: 12-35%) were the common approaches used. CONCLUSIONS: Approximately half of the RCTs report either a covariate-adjusted relative risk or risk difference. Many RCTs lack adequate details on the methods used to estimate covariate-adjusted effects. Of those that do report the approaches used, the binomial model, modified Poisson and to a lesser extent marginal standardisation are the approaches used.
引用
- Thompson J, Watson SI, Middleton L, et al. Estimating relative risks and risk differences in randomised controlled trials: a systematic review of current practice. Trials. 2025. PMID: 39748241. doi:10.1186/s13063-024-08690-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。