研究参与效应及其发现之处:酒精研究相关研究的系统综述
该系统综述旨在识别酒精研究中已被研究的研究参与效应(RPEs),并概述其对自报酒精消费量的估计。共纳入27篇报告,涵盖随机对照试验、试验内研究、受试间实验和定性研究。文献对评估反应性和等待名单设计影响酒精结局提供了相对更强的证据,而与获取知情同意或诱导社会赞许性相反。研究质量、术语和结局测量的差异妨碍了目前对RPEs的全面理解。
要点
- 纳入27篇报告,涉及评估反应性(N=15)、等待名单对照组(N=3)、知情同意(N=2)、社会赞许性(N=3)和霍桑效应等RPEs。
- 文献对评估反应性和等待名单设计影响酒精结局的证据相对更强,与知情同意或诱导社会赞许性相反。
- 研究质量、术语和结局测量的差异妨碍全面理解,需统一术语以提升试验设计和证据确定性。
核心结论
- 研究质量、术语和结局测量的差异妨碍了目前对研究参与效应的全面理解和讨论。
- 改进对研究参与效应及其在酒精研究中潜在长期后果的认识,包括统一术语,将增强试验设计并提高酒精研究证据的确定性。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,旨在识别酒精研究中已被研究的研究参与效应,并概述其对自报酒精消费量的估计。
- 共纳入27篇报告,包括随机对照试验、试验内研究、受试间实验和定性研究。
主要发现
- 评估反应性被研究最多(N=15),其次为等待名单对照组(N=3)、诱导社会赞许性(N=3)、获取知情同意(N=2)和霍桑效应(具体提及N=2,一量性一定性;描述为一般RPE存在N=2)。
- 文献对评估反应性和等待名单设计影响酒精结局提供了相对更强的证据,与获取知情同意或诱导社会赞许性相反。
局限性
- 研究质量、术语和结局测量的差异妨碍了目前对研究参与效应的全面理解和讨论。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The term 'research participation effects' (RPEs) is intended to capture features and artifacts of study design that may affect measured outcomes in ways that introduce bias into research findings, impacting inference and outcome validity. This systematic review aims to identify which RPEs have been studied in the context of alcohol research and provide an overview of estimates of RPEs on self-reported alcohol consumption. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: This systematic review summarizes the available evidence on RPEs in alcohol research. RESULTS: Twenty-seven reports were included in the review. The reports included randomized controlled trials (RCTs), studies-within-a-trial, between-subjects experiments, and qualitative investigations. A range of RPEs were addressed as follows: assessment reactivity (N = 15), being randomized to a waiting list control group (N = 3), the impact of obtaining informed consent (N = 2), experimentally induced social desirability (N = 3), and the Hawthorne effect, either specifically by name (N = 2, one quantitative, one qualitative) or described as general RPE presence (N = 2). The literature provided proportionally stronger evidence in favor of assessment reactivity and waiting list designs affecting alcohol outcomes, contrary to obtaining informed consent or inducing social desirability. CONCLUSION: Variation in study quality, terminology, and outcome measures hinder comprehensive understanding and discussion of RPEs at present. Improved knowledge of RPEs and their potential long-term consequences in alcohol research, including a unified lexicon, would enhance trial design and improve the certainty of evidence in alcohol research.
引用
- Ulfsdotter Gunnarsson K, Collier ES, Bendtsen M, et al. Research participation effects and where to find them: a systematic review of studies on alcohol. J Clin Epidemiol. 2025. PMID: 39800011. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2025.111668
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。