纵向二分类数据的参照组多重插补
针对临床试验中治疗政策策略下治疗偏离后数据缺失的问题,该文提出并描述两种用于纵向二分类结局的参照组多重插补算法:联合建模结合自适应舍入算法,以及联合建模结合潜变量多元正态模型,并通过模拟研究比较两种方法的性能。结果表明,潜变量正态方法通常偏倚略小,两种方法均提供近似信息锚定的推断,但当结局患病率极低(≤10%)时两者可能表现不佳,作者认为潜变量多元正态模型是首选实现方式。
要点
- 该文描述两种纵向二分类数据参照组多重插补算法:联合建模加自适应舍入,以及联合建模加潜变量多元正态模型。
- 模拟研究显示潜变量正态方法偏倚通常略小,两种方法均提供近似信息锚定推断。
- 结局患病率极低(≤10%)时两种方法可能表现不佳,作者认为潜变量多元正态模型为首选。
核心结论
- 参照组多重插补为纵向二分类结局的治疗政策估计目标提供了一种实用的信息锚定工具,潜变量多元正态模型是首选的实现方式。
研究设计与样本
- 该文提出并描述两种用于纵向二分类结局的参照组多重插补算法,并通过模拟研究在广泛场景下比较两种方法的性能。
主要发现
- 在评估的广泛场景中,潜变量正态方法通常偏倚略小,两种方法均提供近似信息锚定的推断。
- 结局越罕见,潜变量正态方法的优势越明显。
- 当结局患病率极低(≤10%)时,两种方法可能表现不佳。
局限性
- 当结局患病率极低(≤10%)时,两种方法可能表现不佳。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: In clinical trials, a treatment policy strategy is often used to handle treatment nonadherence. However, estimation in this context is complicated when data are missing after treatment deviation. Reference-based multiple imputation has been developed for the analysis of a longitudinal continuous outcome in this setting. It has been shown that Rubin's variance estimator ensures that the proportional loss of information due to missing data is approximately the same as that seen in analysis under the missing-at-random assumption for a broad range of commonly used reference-based alternatives; that is it is information anchored. However, the best way to implement reference-based multiple imputation for longitudinal binary data is unclear. METHODS: We formulate and describe two algorithms for implementing reference-based multiple imputation for longitudinal binary outcome data using: (i) joint modeling with the multivariate normal distribution and an adaptive rounding algorithm and (ii) joint modeling with a latent multivariate normal model. A simulation study was performed to compare the properties of the two methods. RESULTS: Across the broad range of scenarios evaluated, the latent normal approach typically gave slightly less bias; both methods provided approximately information anchored inference. The advantage of the latent normal approach was more marked with a rarer outcome. However, both approaches may not perform satisfactorily if the outcome prevalence is very rare, that is, ≤ 10 % $$ \le 10\% $$ . DISCUSSION: Reference-based multiple imputation provides a practical information anchored tool for inferences about the treatment effect for a treatment policy estimand with a longitudinal binary outcome. The latent multivariate normal model is the preferred implementation.
引用
- Cro S, Quartagno M, White IR, et al. Reference-Based Multiple Imputation for Longitudinal Binary Data. Stat Med. 2025. PMID: 39853843. doi:10.1002/sim.10301
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。