文献速递流行病学与生物统计医学教育与科研方法

第4篇:关于证据合成方法学实施中使用逻辑模型与框架的系统综述

Paper 4: a systematic review on the use of logic models and frameworks for methodological conduct of evidence synthesis.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2024-10-30

该研究通过检索三个文献数据库、半结构化访谈和机构网站搜索,识别关注种族健康公平的干预证据合成及公平导向逻辑模型与框架。153篇证据合成中仅2篇明确使用逻辑模型描述干预机制;从访谈和网站搜索识别出7个健康公平框架,按用途分为研究、卫生政策、数字健康解决方案和临床预防服务四类。结论认为证据合成中逻辑模型与框架使用有限,需要更多应用型框架指导证据合成的构建、实施和结果解读。

要点

  • 153篇种族健康公平证据合成中仅2篇明确使用逻辑模型描述干预机制。
  • 识别出7个健康公平框架,按用途分为研究、卫生政策、数字健康解决方案和临床预防服务四类。
  • 7个框架中仅2个提供在证据合成中整合框架或逻辑模型的指导,多数提供定义或考虑种族/种族主义作为健康结构性决定因素的背景信息。

核心结论

  • 在关注种族健康公平的证据合成中,逻辑模型和框架的使用有限。
  • 需要更多应用型框架为关注种族健康公平的证据合成的构建、实施和结果解读提供指导。

研究设计与样本

  • 检索策略包括三个来源:检索三个文献数据库以识别评估改善种族健康公平干预措施的系统综述;与不同群体进行半结构化访谈;以及有针对性的机构网站搜索(如美国国立卫生研究院、美国预防服务工作组)以识别相关逻辑模型和框架。
  • 检索时间为2020年1月1日至2023年1月25日。
  • 采用定性方法识别和描述证据合成中使用的公平导向逻辑模型和框架的关键特征。

主要发现

  • 共识别153篇关注种族健康公平的证据合成,其中2篇明确使用逻辑模型描述干预机制。
  • 通过半结构化访谈和关键网站电子搜索识别出7个现有健康公平框架,按所述目的分类为:为研究提供指导、为卫生政策提供指导、为数字健康解决方案提供指导、为临床预防服务提供指导。
  • 7个框架中2个包含在证据合成中整合框架或逻辑模型的指导,多数提供关于如何定义或考虑种族或种族主义作为健康结构性决定因素的背景信息。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To identify evidence syntheses of health interventions addressing racial health equity reporting the use of equity-focused frameworks and logic models. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: The search strategy included three sources; a search of three bibliographic databases to identify systematic reviews assessing interventions to improve racial health equity, semistructured interviews with diverse group and a targeted organization website searches (eg, National Institute of Health, United States Preventive Services Task Force) to identify relevant logic models and frameworks. The searches were conducted between January 1, 2020, and January 25, 2023. We used a qualitative approach to identify and describe key characteristics of equity-focused logic models and frameworks used in evidence syntheses. RESULTS: Of the 153 racial health equity-focused evidence syntheses identified, two explicitly used logic models to describe the intervention mechanism. We identified seven existing health equity frameworks from semistructured interviews and electronic search of key websites that were categorized by stated purpose as providing guidance for 1) research, 2) health policy, 3) digital health-care solutions, and 4) clinical preventive services. Two out of seven frameworks included guidance on integrating frameworks or logic models in evidence synthesis while the majority provided contextual information on how to define or consider race or racism as a structural determinant of health. CONCLUSION: There is limited use of logic models and frameworks in evidence syntheses addressing racial health equity. There is a need for more applied frameworks providing guidance for framing, conducting and interpreting findings of evidence syntheses addressing racial health equity. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: The goal of this study was to find reviews of health programs that focus on improving racial health equity, and to see if they used special frameworks or models designed to address equity. To do this, we searched three major research databases, conducted interviews with a diverse group of people, and looked at relevant organization websites (like the National Institute of Health and the World Health Organization) between January 2020 and January 2023. We used a qualitative approach to study the key features of these equity-focused frameworks and models. We found 153 reviews focused on racial health equity, but only two of them used logic models to explain the intervention. From interviews and website searches, we identified seven existing health equity frameworks. These were grouped into four categories: research, health policy, digital health care, and clinical preventive services. Only two of these frameworks provided advice on how to use them in evidence reviews, while most focused on understanding how race and racism impact health as a social factor. In conclusion, there is limited use of frameworks and models in reviews about racial health equity. More practical frameworks are needed to help guide the research and interpretation of these reviews.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Francis DK, Pizarro AB, Sathe NA, et al. Paper 4: a systematic review on the use of logic models and frameworks for methodological conduct of evidence synthesis. J Clin Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 39481459. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111583

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。