诊断与预后研究方法学质量评估工具:概览与选择指引
该研究对诊断与预后研究的方法学质量评估工具进行了方法学综述,共识别出14个工具,其中8个针对诊断研究、4个针对预后研究、2个两者兼顾。作者提出五个问题帮助用户根据目的选择合适工具。
要点
- 共识别14个方法学质量评估工具,8个用于诊断研究,4个用于预后研究,2个两者兼顾。
- 工具在目的、范围和内容上存在差异,选择时需明确评估目的和问题。
- 作者提出五个问题辅助选择工具,涉及研究领域、预测模型与检验/因素/标志物的区分、性能评估与增量价值评估等。
核心结论
- 现有诊断与预后研究质量评估工具在目的、范围和内容上存在差异,作者提出的指引可帮助研究者、系统评价者、卫生政策制定者和指南制定者明确目的和问题,从而选择最合适的评估工具。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学综述,检索在线数据库并咨询领域专家,纳入用于评估诊断和/或预后研究中偏倚风险、适用性或其他方法学质量方面的工具,排除仅关注因果研究或报告质量的工具。
主要发现
- 共识别14个质量评估工具,其中8个为诊断研究开发,4个为预后研究开发,2个同时涉及诊断和预后。
- 作者提出五个问题帮助选择工具:关注领域是诊断、预后还是其他;评估对象是预测模型还是检验/因素/标志物;评估目的是仅评估性能还是评估增量价值;是否比较两个或多个检验/因素/标志物/模型;是仅评估偏倚风险还是也评估其他质量方面。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议用户根据自身目的或问题,利用五个问题明确评估焦点,从而选择最合适的方法学质量评估工具。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Multiple tools exist for assessing the methodological quality of diagnosis and prognosis research. It can be challenging to decide on when to use which tool. We aimed to provide an overview of existing methodological quality assessment (QA) tools for diagnosis and prognosis studies, highlight the overlap and differences among these tools, and to provide guidance for choosing the appropriate tool. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We performed a methodological review of tools designed for assessing risk of bias, applicability, or other aspects related to methodological quality in studies investigating tests/factors/markers/models for classifying or predicting a current (diagnosis) and/or future (prognosis) health state. Tools focusing exclusively on causal research or on reporting quality were excluded. Guidance was subsequently developed to assist in choosing an appropriate QA tool. RESULTS: We identified 14 QA tools, eight of which were developed for assessment of diagnosis studies, four for prognosis studies, and two addressing both. We propose a set of five questions to help guide the process of choosing a QA tool based on the purpose or question of the user: whether the focus is on (1) diagnosis, prognosis, or another domain; (2) a prediction model vs a test/factor/marker; (3) evaluating simply the performance of a test/factor/marker vs assessing its added value over other variables; (4) comparing two or more tests/factors/markers/models; and (5) whether the user aims to assess only risk of bias or also other quality aspects. CONCLUSION: Existing QA tools for appraising diagnosis and prognosis studies vary in purpose, scope, and contents. Our guidance may help researchers, systematic reviewers, health policy makers, and guideline developers in specifying their purpose and question to select the most appropriate QA tool for their assessment. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Methodological quality assessment (QA) tools provide a set of criteria to evaluate how well a medical study was done and how trustworthy its results are. To accurately assess a study's quality, it is important to use a QA tool that matches the type of medical study. However, with many QA tools available for different study types, choosing the right one can be challenging, especially for diagnosis and prognosis studies (ie, studies that evaluate tests, factors, markers, and models used for diagnosis and prognosis). To assist in selecting the best QA tools for diagnostic and prognostic studies, we created an overview of available tools and practical tips for choosing the most appropriate one. After searching online databases and consulting experts in the field, we identified 14 QA tools specific to diagnostic and prognostic studies. Additionally, we developed five key questions to guide users in choosing the best tool for their study. While the 14 QA tools differ in their focus and content, our guidance simplifies the process of choosing the right tool and helps users refine their research question.
引用
- Kaul T, Kellerhuis BE, Damen JAA, et al. Methodological quality assessment tools for diagnosis and prognosis research: overview and guidance. J Clin Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 39536993. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111609
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。