系统综述的又一个问题:一项动态综述更新
该动态系统综述更新检索2022年5月至2023年5月发表的文献,新增152篇相关文章使总数达637篇。新发现系统综述作者团队性别多样性不足这一问题,使系统综述问题总数增至68个;更新还揭示COVID-19快速科学、方法学或报告指南引用未能预测高质量、既得利益影响结论等新兴主题,并基于77项元流行病学研究分析缺陷对结论的影响。
要点
- 系统综述问题总数增至68个,新增作者团队性别多样性不足问题。
- 新增152篇文献使相关文章总数达637篇。
- 77项元流行病学研究开始检验哪些问题威胁系统综述结论的可靠性。
核心结论
- 本动态综述捕捉到文献中关于综述作者团队构成的新兴主题,并提示其对系统综述公平性报告的可能影响。
- 作者建议元研究应从仅记录已确立的问题转向理解系统综述较少为人知的问题或后果。
研究设计与样本
- 动态系统综述更新,重新运行文献检索识别2022年5月至2023年5月期间发表或索引的文章,采用主题分析在全面性、严谨性、透明性和客观性四个领域对文章和问题进行编码。
主要发现
- 新增152篇纳入文章使相关文章总数达到637篇。
- 新问题(系统综述作者团队缺乏性别多样性)使系统综述问题总数增至68个。
- 本次更新揭示新兴主题包括:COVID-19系统综述的快速科学;方法学或报告指南的引用未能预测高质量的方法学或报告质量;既得利益对系统综述结论的影响。
- 本次更新基于637篇纳入文章中的77项元流行病学研究,报告已识别缺陷在何处影响系统综述的结论。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In February 2023, the Journal of Clinical Epidemiology published 'The Problems with Systematic Reviews: A Living Systematic Review.' In updating this living review for the first time a new problem and several themes relating to research culture have emerged. METHODS: Literature searches were rerun to identify articles published or indexed between May 2022 and May 2023. Thematic analysis coded articles and problems across four domains of systematic review conduct (1. comprehensive, 2. rigour, 3. transparent, 4. objective). RESULTS: One hundred fifty-two newly included articles bring the total number of relevant articles to 637. A new problem (the lack of gender diversity of systematic review author teams) brings the total number of problems with systematic reviews up to 68. This update also reveals emerging themes such as: fast science from systematic reviews on COVID-19; the failure of citation of methodological or reporting guidelines to predict high-quality methodological or reporting quality; and the influence of vested interests on systematic review conclusions. These findings coupled with a proliferation of research waste from "me-too" meta-research articles highlighting well-established problems in systematic reviews underscores the need for reforms in research culture to address the incentives for producing and publishing research papers. This update also reports where the identified flaws in systematic reviews affect their conclusions drawing on 77 meta-epidemiological studies from the total 637 included articles. These meta-meta-analytic studies begin the important work of examining which problems threaten the reliability and validity of treatment effects or conclusions derived from systematic reviews. CONCLUSION: This living review has captured an emerging theme in the published literature relating to the composition of the review author team and highlights a potential effect on the equity reporting of the systematic reviews. We recommend that meta-research endeavors evolve from merely documenting well-established issues to understanding lesser-known problems or consequences to systematic reviews.
引用
- Uttley L, Weng Y, Falzon L, et al. Yet another problem with systematic reviews: a living review update. J Clin Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 39542225. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111608
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。