社会科学领域观察性系统综述与Meta分析的报告完整性有待提高:一项横断面调查
该研究基于Web of Science社会科学核心索引和中国知网社会科学核心索引,检索2012年至2022年12月前发表的观察性系统综述与Meta分析(OSRMA),采用双盲流程进行文献检索、筛选和数据提取,共纳入634篇(英文期刊349篇、中文期刊285篇)。平均报告完整率为54.6%,英文综述报告完整性高于中文(55.2% vs 53.9%)。检索策略报告被忽视,英文综述平均报告率42.9%、中文综述25.8%。作者建议将Meta-analysis Of Observational Studies in Epidemiology指南适配社会科学情境并推广使用。
要点
- 共纳入634篇OSRMA,英文期刊349篇、中文期刊285篇,平均报告完整率54.6%。
- 英文综述报告完整性高于中文(55.2% vs 53.9%)。
- 检索策略报告被忽视,英文综述平均报告率42.9%、中文综述25.8%。
核心结论
- 社会科学领域OSRMA报告质量低,中文期刊尤为明显。
- 作者建议将Meta-analysis Of Observational Studies in Epidemiology指南适配社会科学情境,并在该领域研究者和审稿人中推广使用。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面调查,通过Web of Science社会科学核心索引和中国知网社会科学核心索引检索2012年至2022年12月前发表的OSRMA。
- 文献检索、筛选和数据提取采用双盲流程。
- 共纳入634篇OSRMA,其中英文期刊349篇、中文期刊285篇。
主要发现
- 平均报告完整率为54.6%,英文综述报告完整性高于中文(55.2% vs 53.9%)。
- 所有综述在背景、方法和结论方面报告较好,平均报告率分别为68.1%、65.2%和88.8%。
- 检索策略报告被忽视,英文综述平均报告率42.9%、中文综述25.8%,尤其涉及检索人员资质、纳入所有可用研究的努力、所用检索软件、处理未发表研究和联系作者等方面。
- 这些综述的报告透明度受多种综述因素统计学显著影响,包括期刊语言、发表年份、作者数量、遵循的报告指南和资金来源声明。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议将Meta-analysis Of Observational Studies in Epidemiology指南适配社会科学情境,并在该领域研究者和审稿人中推广使用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate and compare the reporting quality of observational systematic reviews and meta-analyses (OSRMA) published in Chinese- and English-language social science journals using the Meta-analyses Of Observational Studies in Epidemiology guideline. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We searched the Social Science Core Index via Web of Science and the Chinese Social Science Core Index via China National Knowledge Infrastructure databases for OSRMAs published from 2012 to 2022 (before December 2022). The process of literature search, selection, and data extraction were performed double blind. RESULTS: We identified 634 OSRMAs, of which 349 were in English-language journals and 285 in Chinese-language journals. The mean reporting completeness rate was 54.6%, and reviews in English had higher reporting completeness than those in Chinese (55.2% vs 53.9%). All the reviews reported well on background, method, and conclusion, with average reporting rates of 68.1%, 65.2%, and 88.8%, respectively. However, the reporting of search strategy was ignored, with an average rate of 42.9% for reviews in English and 25.8% for reviews in Chinese, especially on the qualifications of searchers, effort to include all available studies, search software used, handling unpublished studies, and contact with authors. The reporting transparency of these reviews was statistically significantly influenced by multiple review factors, including the language of journals, year of publication, the number of authors, the reporting guideline followed, and the declaration of funding source. CONCLUSION: OSRMAs in social science demonstrate low reporting quality, especially in Chinese-language journals. We suggest adapting the Meta-analyses Of Observational Studies in Epidemiology guideline to the social science context and promoting its use among researchers and reviewers in this field.
引用
- Guo L, Xing X, Ren J, et al. The reporting completeness of observational systematic reviews and meta-analysis in social science could be improved: a cross-sectional survey. J Clin Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 39384164. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111548
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。