第2篇:半结构化访谈的主题
该研究通过虚拟半结构化访谈,探讨如何在系统综述中定义种族健康公平,以及如何配置人员、开展、传播、维持和评价针对种族健康公平的系统综述。29名主要来自美国的利益相关者参与,提出应关注权力体系、不公正、健康社会决定因素和交叉性,并建议在综述范围、方法、纳入证据及团队构成上做出改变。
要点
- 利益相关者将种族健康公平概念化为涉及权力体系、不公正、健康社会决定因素和交叉性。
- 建议将具有生活经验的社区成员纳入综述团队。
- 建议调整综述范围、方法和纳入证据,并拓宽证据设计以涵盖实施和可及性。
核心结论
- 利益相关者识别出在系统综述的资助、人员配置、开展、传播和实施中做出改变,以中心化种族健康公平。
- 采取这些步骤需要明确的成功标准、支持变革性改变的证据基础,以及利益相关者之间关于前进方向的共识。
研究设计与样本
- 研究采用虚拟半结构化访谈,随后使用NVivo进行结构化编码和定性分析。
- 29名参与者主要来自美国,包括患者、社区代表、系统综述作者、临床医生、指南制定者、原始研究者和资助者。
主要发现
- 利益相关者在概念化种族健康公平时提到权力体系、不公正、健康社会决定因素和交叉性。
- 他们强调将具有生活经验的社区成员纳入综述团队。
- 他们建议对系统综述的范围、方法和纳入证据做出改变,例如调整综述方法以在优先确定综述主题、制定关键问题和检索策略以及指定结局时纳入种族健康公平考量,并拓宽证据以包括涉及实施和可及性的设计。
- 利益相关者指出,持续努力将种族健康公平置于系统综述中心需要资源、时间、培训并向资助者展示价值。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: In the context of profound and persistent racial health inequities, we sought to understand how to define racial health equity in the context of systematic reviews and how to staff, conduct, disseminate, sustain, and evaluate systematic reviews that address racial health equity. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: The study consisted of virtual, semistructured interviews followed by structured coding and qualitative analyses using NVivo. RESULTS: Twenty-nine individuals, primarily United States-based, including patients, community representatives, systematic reviewers, clinicians, guideline developers, primary researchers, and funders, participated in this study. These interest holders brought up systems of power, injustice, social determinants of health, and intersectionality when conceptualizing racial health equity. They also emphasized including community members with lived experience in review teams. They suggested making changes to systematic review scope, methods, and eligible evidence (such as adapting review methods to include racial health equity considerations in prioritizing topics for reviews, formulating key questions and searches, and specifying outcomes) and broadening evidence to include designs that address implementation and access. Interest holders noted that sustained efforts to center racial health equity in systematic reviews require resources, time, training, and demonstrating value to funders. CONCLUSION: Interest holders identified changes to the funding, staffing, conduct, dissemination, and implementation of systematic reviews to center racial health equity. Action on these steps requires clear standards for success, an evidence base to support transformative changes, and consensus among interest holders on the way forward.
引用
- Ali R, Daniel C, Duque T, et al. Paper 2: themes from semistructured interviews. J Clin Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 39442674. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111574
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。