析因自适应多臂多阶段(FAST)临床试验的设计考量
多臂多阶段(MAMS)设计涵盖自适应与多臂设计,析因设计与其结合形成FAST设计。本文通过模拟研究评估分析类型、分析时机及多结局效应量对FAST试验操作特性的影响,结果表明FAST设计可提供框架,可能优于MAMS或析因试验,但设计实施决策对操作特性影响很大,需在规划阶段充分探索。
要点
- FAST设计结合析因与MAMS设计,可能提高效率。
- 分析类型、时机和效应量影响试验操作特性。
- 设计实施决策需在规划阶段充分探索。
核心结论
- FAST类试验可能提供与MAMS和析因设计相似的获益,但所选设计方面需在规划阶段充分探索。
研究设计与样本
- 模拟研究评估分析类型、分析时机及多结局观察到的效应量对FAST设计试验操作特性的影响。
主要发现
- 模拟研究表明,所提出的FAST试验设计类别可提供框架,可能相对MAMS或析因试验等其他试验设计提供改进。
- 设计实施决策(如整个试验中分析时机和类型)可对试验操作特性产生很大影响。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Multi-Arm, Multi-Stage (MAMS) clinical trial designs allow for multiple therapies to be compared across a spectrum of clinical trial phases. MAMS designs fall under several overarching design groups, including adaptive designs (AD) and multi-arm (MA) designs. Factorial clinical trials designs represent a combination of factorial and MAMS trial designs and can provide increased efficiency relative to fixed, traditional designs. We explore design choices associated with Factorial Adaptive Multi-Arm Multi-Stage (FAST) designs, which represent the combination of factorial and MAMS designs. METHODS: Simulation studies were conducted to assess the impact of the type of analyses, the timing of analyses, and the effect size observed across multiple outcomes on trial operating characteristics for a FAST design. Given multiple outcomes types assessed within the hypothetical trial, the primary analysis approach for each assessment varied depending on data type. RESULTS: The simulation studies demonstrate that the proposed class of FAST trial designs can offer a framework to potentially provide improvements relative to other trial designs, such as a MAMS or factorial trial. Further, we note that the design implementation decisions, such as the timing and type of analyses conducted throughout trial, can have a great impact on trial operating characteristics. CONCLUSIONS: Motivated by a trial currently under design, our work shows that the FAST category of trial can potentially offer benefits similar to both MAMS and factorial designs; however, the chosen design aspects which can be included in a FAST trial need to be thoroughly explored during the planning phase.
引用
- Beall J, Elm J, Semler MW, et al. Design considerations for Factorial Adaptive Multi-Arm Multi-Stage (FAST) clinical trials. Trials. 2024. PMID: 39261887. doi:10.1186/s13063-024-08400-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。