使用在线方法招募心理健康临床试验参与者:RE-MIND研究的考量与建议
RE-MIND研究采用混合方法,包括对97项近期发表的心理健康随机对照试验或可行性/试点研究的证据综述,以及对23名关键利益相关者的定性研究,第三工作包基于前两部分结果提出在线招募策略的考量与实践建议,以改善试验效率与包容性。
要点
- 临床试验参与者应反映最终接受干预的人群,以保证外部有效性。
- RE-MIND研究综合证据综述与利益相关者定性研究结果提出建议。
- 原文提出一系列考量与实践建议,以最大化利用在线招募方法。
核心结论
- 为保证外部有效性,临床试验参与者应反映最终将接受所测试干预措施(若被证明有效)的人群。
- 为指导研究者选择包容性招募策略,研究团队制定了一系列关于如何最大化利用在线招募方法的考量与实践建议。
研究设计与样本
- RE-MIND研究采用混合方法,包含三个工作包。
- 工作包I为证据综述,纳入97项近期发表的心理健康随机对照试验或可行性/试点研究,评估在线与线下招募的影响。
- 工作包II为定性研究,调查23名关键利益相关者对心理健康临床试验中使用在线招募方法的体验。
- 工作包III结合工作包I和II的结果,提出心理健康临床试验中使用在线招募策略的建议。
- 本评论文章呈现第三工作包的结果。
主要发现
- 工作包I和II的研究结果已在其他文献中发表。
- 在线招募策略的使用证据不一。
- 本评论文章呈现第三工作包的结果,即关于在线招募方法的考量与实践建议列表。
临床怎么用
- 原文提出一系列考量与实践建议,以指导研究者选择包容性招募策略并最大化利用在线招募方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Ensuring diversity in clinical trials can be a challenge, which may be exacerbated when recruiting vulnerable populations, such as participants with mental health illness. As recruitment continues to be the major cause of trial delays, researchers are turning to online recruitment strategies, e.g. social media, to reach a wider population and reduce recruitment time and costs. There is mixed evidence for the use of online recruitment strategies; therefore, the REcruitment in Mental health trials: broadening the 'net', opportunities for INclusivity through online methoDs (RE-MIND) study aimed to identify evidence and provide guidance for use of online strategies in recruitment to mental health trials, with a focus on whether online strategies can enhance inclusivity. This commentary, as part of the RE-MIND study, focusses on providing recommendations for recruitment strategy selection in future research with the aim to improve trial efficiency. A mixed-methods approach was employed involving three work packages: (I) an evidence review of a cohort of 97 recently published randomised controlled trials/feasibility or pilot studies in mental health to assess the impact of online versus offline recruitment; (II) a qualitative study investigating the experiences of n = 23 key stakeholders on use of an online recruitment approach in mental health clinical trials; (III) combining the results of WP1 and WP2 to produce recommendations on the use of an online recruitment strategy in mental health clinical trials. The findings from WP1 and 2 have been published elsewhere; this commentary represents the results of the third work package. CONCLUSION: For external validity, clinical trial participants should reflect the populations that will ultimately receive the interventions being tested, if proven effective. To guide researchers on their options for inclusive recruitment strategies, we have developed a list of considerations and practical recommendations on how to maximise the use of online recruitment methods.
引用
- Iflaifel M, Hall CL, Green HR, et al. Using online methods to recruit participants into mental health clinical trials: considerations and recommendations from the RE-MIND study. Trials. 2024. PMID: 39244623. doi:10.1186/s13063-024-08435-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。