指南与共识流行病学与生物统计医学教育与科研方法

创伤性脑损伤与刑事司法系统临床实践指南中的公平性考量:一项系统综述

Equity considerations in clinical practice guidelines for traumatic brain injury and the criminal justice system: A systematic review.
指南 / 共识 · PLoS Med · 2024-08-12

本系统综述纳入57部创伤性脑损伤(TBI)指南和6部刑事司法系统(CJS)指南,评估CJS在TBI指南中的体现、TBI在CJS指南中的体现以及公平性在CJS指南中的考量。14部TBI指南涉及CJS相关信息但仅1部给出具体推荐,2部CJS指南提及监狱人群TBI患病率且1部具体推荐在健康评估时考虑TBI。公平性最佳实践和弱势群体参与在CJS指南中普遍缺乏。

要点

  • 57部TBI指南中仅14部涉及CJS,仅1部具体推荐在法医背景职业评估时考虑法律影响。
  • 6部CJS指南中仅2部提及监狱人群TBI患病率,仅1部具体推荐健康评估时考虑TBI。
  • TBI与CJS指南均仅覆盖CJS单一环节,以警务和惩教为主,CJS指南缺乏公平性最佳实践。

核心结论

  • 本综述为在TBI指南中考虑CJS参与、并在CJS指南中推进公平性提供了基础。
  • 作者认为开展研究(包括调查与CJS各环节交叉个体的TBI筛查流程)以及在指南制定中利用公平性评估工具是增强该弱势群体医疗公平性的关键步骤。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,检索MEDLINE、Embase、CINAHL、PsycINFO、定向网站、谷歌搜索及已纳入指南的参考文献列表,TBI指南检索于2021年11月和2023年3月,CJS指南检索于2022年5月和2023年3月。
  • 纳入57部TBI指南和6部CJS指南,计算包含TBI或CJS特定内容的指南比例,进行定性内容分析,并利用公平性评估工具了解公平性是否及如何被考虑。

主要发现

  • 57部TBI指南中14部包含与CJS相关的信息,但仅1部给出具体推荐:在法医背景的职业评估中考虑法律影响。
  • 6部CJS指南中2部承认监狱个体中TBI的患病率,其中1部具体推荐在健康评估时考虑TBI。
  • TBI指南和CJS指南均仅提供针对CJS单一环节的证据,以警务和惩教为主。
  • CJS指南在制定过程中缺乏公平性最佳实践的应用和弱势群体的参与。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 本综述检索以英语进行,可能遗漏非英语指南。
  • 本综述未系统检索指南之外关于与CJS交叉的TBI个体的研究,故无法评述未纳入指南的证据。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is disproportionately prevalent among individuals who intersect or are involved with the criminal justice system (CJS). In the absence of appropriate care, TBI-related impairments, intersecting social determinants of health, and the lack of TBI awareness in CJS settings can lead to lengthened sentences, serious disciplinary charges, and recidivism. However, evidence suggests that most clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) overlook equity and consequently, the needs of disadvantaged groups. As such, this review addressed the research question "To what extent are (1) intersections with the CJS considered in CPGs for TBI, (2) TBI considered in CPGs for CJS, and (3) equity considered in CPGs for CJS?". METHODS AND FINDINGS: CPGs were identified from electronic databases (MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, PsycINFO), targeted websites, Google Search, and reference lists of identified CPGs on November 2021 and March 2023 (CPGs for TBI) and May 2022 and March 2023 (CPGs for CJS). Only CPGs for TBI or CPGs for CJS were included. We calculated the proportion of CPGs that included TBI- or CJS-specific content, conducted a qualitative content analysis to understand how evidence regarding TBI and the CJS was integrated in the CPGs, and utilised equity assessment tools to understand if and how equity was considered. Fifty-seven CPGs for TBI and 6 CPGs for CJS were included in this review. Fourteen CPGs for TBI included information relevant to the CJS, but only 1 made a concrete recommendation to consider legal implications during vocational evaluation in the forensic context. Two CPGs for CJS acknowledged the prevalence of TBI among individuals in prison and one specifically recommended considering TBI during health assessments. Both CPGs for TBI and CPGs for CJS provided evidence specific to a single facet of the CJS, predominantly in policing and corrections. The use of equity best practices and the involvement of disadvantaged groups in the development process were lacking among CPGs for CJS. We acknowledge limitations of the review, including that our searches were conducted in English language and thus, we may have missed other non-English language CPGs in this review. We further recognise that we are unable to comment on evidence that is not integrated in the CPGs, as we did not systematically search for research on individuals with TBI who intersect with the CJS, outside of CPGs. CONCLUSIONS: Findings from this review provide the foundation to consider CJS involvement in CPGs for TBI and to advance equity in CPGs for CJS. Conducting research, including investigating the process of screening for TBI with individuals who intersect with all facets of the CJS, and utilizing equity assessment tools in guideline development are critical steps to enhance equity in healthcare for this disadvantaged group.

来源:PLoS Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Colclough Z, Estrella MJ, Joyce JM, et al. Equity considerations in clinical practice guidelines for traumatic brain injury and the criminal justice system: A systematic review. PLoS Med. 2024. PMID: 39134041. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1004418

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。