文献速递流行病学与生物统计真实世界研究与卫生经济

用医疗系统数据补充系统评价发现:美国医疗保健研究与质量局循证实践中心项目的试点项目

Supplementing systematic review findings with healthcare system data: pilot projects from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Evidence-based Practice Center program.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2024-08-07

美国医疗保健研究与质量局循证实践中心项目开展三个试点项目,分别针对婴儿期癫痫、偏头痛和髋部骨折,利用电子健康记录数据补充系统评价证据缺口。两项分析填补了证据缺口并提高证据确定性,但电子健康记录数据关键临床变量捕获能力有限,试点项目完成时间估计为283至595小时,增加的努力和资源带来的增量价值有限。

要点

  • 三个试点项目分别针对婴儿期癫痫、偏头痛和髋部骨折,利用电子健康记录数据补充系统评价证据缺口。
  • 两项补充数据分析填补了系统评价的证据缺口并提高证据确定性,第三项填补了医疗系统知识缺口。
  • 在系统评价同时进行补充数据分析可行,但增加大量时间和资源,估计完成试点项目总小时数各中心为283至595小时,增量价值有限。

核心结论

  • 用电子健康记录数据分析补充现有系统评价资源密集,整个过程需要专业技能。
  • 虽然利用电子健康记录数据开展研究在生成真实世界证据和填补知识缺口方面有巨大潜力,但这些数据可能尚未准备好与系统评价常规一起使用。

研究设计与样本

  • 美国医疗保健研究与质量局通过循证实践中心项目实施试点项目,以了解利用医疗系统数据补充系统评价发现的可行性、益处和挑战。
  • 三个承包商(每个是位于不同医疗系统的循证实践中心)选择其中心最近完成的系统评价,并确定电子健康记录数据可能解决的证据缺口。
  • 所有试点项目主题均针对临床问题,而非循证实践中心报告中常见的护理提供、护理组织或护理差异主题。
  • 各循证实践中心涉及的主题领域包括婴儿期癫痫、偏头痛和髋部骨折。
  • 工作组于2022至2023年每月开会讨论试点项目的挑战和经验教训。

主要发现

  • 两项补充数据分析填补了系统评价中确定的证据缺口(提高证据确定性、改善适用性),第三项填补了医疗系统知识缺口。
  • 项目挑战归为三个主题:监管和后勤问题、数据收集和分析、结果的解释和呈现。
  • 由于电子健康记录内数据不一致或缺失,捕获关键临床变量的能力有限,这是一个主要局限性。
  • 工作组发现,在系统评价同时进行补充数据分析是可行的,但为审查过程增加大量时间和资源(估计完成试点项目总小时数各循证实践中心为283至595小时)。
  • 增加的努力和资源带来的增量价值有限。

局限性

  • 由于电子健康记录内数据不一致或缺失,捕获关键临床变量的能力有限,这是一个主要局限性。
  • 在系统评价同时进行补充数据分析是可行的,但为审查过程增加大量时间和资源(估计完成试点项目总小时数各循证实践中心为283至595小时)。
  • 增加的努力和资源带来的增量价值有限。
  • 虽然利用电子健康记录数据开展研究在生成真实世界证据和填补知识缺口方面有巨大潜力,但这些数据可能尚未准备好与系统评价常规一起使用。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: The US Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, through the Evidence-based Practice Center (EPC) Program, aims to provide health system decision makers with the highest-quality evidence to inform clinical decisions. However, limitations in the literature may lead to inconclusive findings in EPC systematic reviews (SRs). The EPC Program conducted pilot projects to understand the feasibility, benefits, and challenges of utilizing health system data to augment SR findings to support confidence in healthcare decision-making based on real-world experiences. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Three contractors (each an EPC located at a different health system) selected a recently completed SR conducted by their center and identified an evidence gap that electronic health record (EHR) data might address. All pilot project topics addressed clinical questions as opposed to care delivery, care organization, or care disparities topics that are common in EPC reports. Topic areas addressed by each EPC included infantile epilepsy, migraine, and hip fracture. EPCs also tracked additional resources needed to conduct supplemental analyses. The workgroup met monthly in 2022-2023 to discuss challenges and lessons learned from the pilot projects. RESULTS: Two supplemental data analyses filled an evidence gap identified in the SRs (raised certainty of evidence, improved applicability) and the third filled a health system knowledge gap. Project challenges fell under three themes: regulatory and logistical issues, data collection and analysis, and interpretation and presentation of findings. Limited ability to capture key clinical variables given inconsistent or missing data within the EHR was a major limitation. The workgroup found that conducting supplemental data analysis alongside an SR was feasible but adds considerable time and resources to the review process (estimated total hours to complete pilot projects ranged from 283 to 595 across EPCs), and that the increased effort and resources added limited incremental value. CONCLUSION: Supplementing existing SRs with analyses of EHR data is resource intensive and requires specialized skillsets throughout the process. While using EHR data for research has immense potential to generate real-world evidence and fill knowledge gaps, these data may not yet be ready for routine use alongside SRs.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Holmer HK, Iyer S, Fiordalisi CV, et al. Supplementing systematic review findings with healthcare system data: pilot projects from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Evidence-based Practice Center program. J Clin Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 39097175. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111484

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。