拉丁美洲专家组成员认为GRADE-ADOLOPMENT有用且对将推荐意见情境化很重要
本研究通过混合方法后评估(问卷调查和半结构化访谈)了解拉丁美洲指南制定组应用GRADE-ADOLOPMENT改编美国血液学会静脉血栓栓塞症管理指南的经验。14名成员中11人回复问卷、8人参与访谈,受访者总体满意,认为该方法在资源有限国家有用,但面临本地数据收集、推荐优先级排序和出版周期长等挑战。
要点
- 受访专家对改编指南感到「大部分」或「完全」满意
- 8名受访专家组成员同意GRADE-ADOLOPMENT在资源有限国家有用
- 专家组成员强调改编推荐时应考虑资源、可行性和成本效果等证据到决策标准
核心结论
- GRADE-ADOLOPMENT是促进临床实践指南在新情境中改编和采纳的重要工具。
- 指南制定组对使用GRADE-ADOLOPMENT方法的总体体验感到满意。
- 若可获得稳健的区域证据、更多可改编的推荐意见以及更高效的指南制作时间线,他们的体验本可得到优化。
研究设计与样本
- 采用混合方法后评估,包括自填式问卷调查和半结构化访谈。
- 评估对象为应用GRADE-ADOLOPMENT改编美国血液学会静脉血栓栓塞症管理指南的拉丁美洲指南制定组。
- 14名指南制定组成员中,11人(包括9名专家组成员和2名方法学家)提供了问卷回复,8人参与了访谈。
主要发现
- 受访者对该改编指南感到「大部分」或「完全」满意。
- 接受调查的8名专家组成员同意GRADE-ADOLOPMENT在资源有限的国家有用。
- 专家组成员表示,起初对流程的理解有所顾虑,但在完成工作坊培训并积累经验后,对应用GRADE的能力信心增强。
- 专家组成员重申,在改编推荐意见时考虑证据到决策标准(即资源、可行性和成本效果)的重要性。
- 指南制定组在收集本地和区域数据、在考虑区域内多样性的同时确定推荐意见的优先级以及漫长的出版周期方面遇到了挑战,尽管后者源于与GRADE-ADOLOPMENT无关的程序。
关键数值与推荐
- 14名指南制定组成员中11人提供了问卷回复,其中9名为专家组成员、2名为方法学家。
- 8名专家组成员参与了访谈。
- 接受调查的8名专家组成员同意GRADE-ADOLOPMENT在资源有限的国家有用。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 指南制定组在收集本地和区域数据方面遇到挑战。
- 指南制定组在考虑区域内多样性的同时确定推荐意见优先级方面遇到挑战。
- 指南制定组遇到漫长的出版周期挑战,尽管后者源于与GRADE-ADOLOPMENT无关的程序。
- 受访者最初对流程的理解有所顾虑。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE)-ADOLOPMENT is widely applied to efficiently use existing credible guidelines and contextualize them to a target setting. To highlight the experiences of a Latin American Guideline Development Group (GDG) applying GRADE-ADOLOPMENT to adapt the American Society of Hematology's clinical practice guideline on managing venous thromboembolisms (VTEs) in Latin America. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We employed a mixed-method postevaluation using self-administered surveys and semistructured interviews. We assessed the Latin American GDG (1) general satisfaction and confidence using the approach, (2) their ratings on the usefulness, appropriateness, and importance of GRADE-ADOLOPMENT and its tools to inform their judgements, and (3) any additional facilitators and barriers to refine the process. RESULTS: Eleven of the 14 GDG members, including nine panelists and two methodologists, provided survey responses and eight participated in the interview. Respondents felt "mostly" or "completely" satisfied with the adapted guideline. Eight panelists who were surveyed agree that GRADE-ADOLOPMENT is useful in countries with limited resources. Although panelists expressed initial apprehensions in their understanding of the process, they demonstrated enhanced confidence in their capacity to apply GRADE after completing workshop training and by acquiring experience. Panelists reiterated the importance of considering evidence-to-decision (EtD) criteria (ie, resources, feasibility, and cost-effectiveness) when adapting recommendations. The GDG encountered challenges with collecting local and regional data, prioritizing recommendations while considering intraregional diversity, and the lengthy publication period, although the latter stemmed from procedures not related to GRADE-ADOLOPMENT. CONCLUSIONS: GRADE-ADOLOPMENT is an important tool to facilitate the adaptation and uptake of clinical practice guidelines in novel settings. The GDG felt satisfied with their overall experience using the GRADE-ADOLOPMENT approach. However, their experience could have been optimized if they had access to robust regional evidence, more recommendations to adapt from, and worked with more efficient guideline production timelines.
引用
- Nasir ZH, Lotfi T, Yepes Nuñez JJ, et al. Latin American panelists find GRADE-ADOLOPMENT useful and important to contextualize recommendations in their region. J Clin Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 39094929. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111483
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。