指南与共识流行病学与生物统计

COVID-19公共卫生指南中的价值观与偏好:一项系统综述

Values and preferences in COVID-19 public health guidelines: a systematic review.
指南 / 共识 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2024-07-20

该系统综述检索eCOVID-19 RecMap平台(截至2023年7月)和 Guidelines International Network Library(截至2024年5月),纳入130部COVID-19公共卫生指南,评估其对价值观与偏好的考虑。28部(21.5%)指南考虑了价值观与偏好,多数用于评估推荐可接受性(23部,82.1%)并引用已发表研究(25部,89.3%),仅8部(28.6%)有非专业人士参与指南制定组,无一部对价值观与偏好相关文献进行系统综述。作者结论认为多数指南未考虑价值观与偏好,建议指南制定者识别危机情境下考虑价值观与偏好的高效方法。

要点

  • 130部指南中仅28部(21.5%)考虑了价值观与偏好。
  • 考虑价值观与偏好的指南中,23部(82.1%)用于评估推荐可接受性,25部(89.3%)引用已发表研究。
  • 仅8部(28.6%)有非专业人士参与制定组,无一部进行价值观与偏好文献的系统综述。

核心结论

  • 多数COVID-19公共卫生指南未考虑价值观与偏好,考虑时也常不理想;对价值观与偏好的忽视可能部分导致了COVID-19政策的分裂和不受欢迎。
  • 鉴于未来可能发生卫生紧急事件,作者建议指南制定者识别危机情境下考虑价值观与偏好的高效方法。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,检索eCOVID-19 RecMap平台(截至2023年7月)和Guidelines International Network Library(截至2024年5月),纳入涉及疫苗接种、口罩、隔离、封锁、旅行限制、接触者追踪、感染监测和学校关闭推荐的COVID-19公共卫生指南。
  • 共纳入130部指南,其中41部(31.5%)由国家组织发布,70部(53.8%)由国际组织发布,19部(14.6%)由专业学会和协会发布。
  • 评审员独立且双人审核指南对价值观与偏好的考虑情况。

主要发现

  • 28部(21.5%)指南考虑了价值观与偏好。
  • 在考虑价值观与偏好的指南中,23部(82.1%)用于评估推荐的可接受性,25部(89.3%)引用已发表研究。
  • 仅8部(28.6%)指南有非专业人士作为指南制定组成员参与。
  • 无一部指南对涉及价值观与偏好的文献进行系统综述。

临床怎么用

  • 作者建议指南制定者识别危机情境下考虑价值观与偏好的高效方法。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Internationally accepted standards for trustworthy guidelines include the necessity to ground recommendations in values and preferences. Considering values and preferences respects the rights of citizens to participate in health decision-making and ensures that guidelines align with the needs and priorities of the communities they are intended to serve. Early anecdotal reports suggest that COVID-19 public health guidelines did not consider values and preferences. To capture and characterize whether and how COVID-19 public health guidelines considered values and preferences. METHODS: We performed a systematic review of COVID-19 public health guidelines. We searched the eCOVID-19 RecMap platform-a comprehensive international catalog of COVID-19 guidelines-up to July 2023 and the Guidelines International Network Library-an international library of guidelines published or endorsed by Guidelines International Network member organizations-up to May 2024. We included guidelines that made recommendations addressing vaccination, masking, isolation, lockdowns, travel restrictions, contact tracing, infection surveillance, and school closures. Reviewers worked independently and in duplicate to review guidelines for consideration of values and preferences. RESULTS: Our search yielded 130 eligible guidelines, of which 41 (31.5%) were published by national organizations, 70 (53.8%) by international organizations, and 19 (14.6%) by professional societies and associations. Twenty-eight (21.5%) guidelines considered values and preferences. Among guidelines that considered values and preferences, most did so to assess the acceptability of recommendations (23; 82.1%) and by referencing published research (25; 89.3%). Guidelines only occasionally engaged laypersons as part of the guideline development group (8; 28.6%). None of the guidelines performed systematic reviews of the literature addressing values and preferences. CONCLUSION: Most COVID-19 public health guidelines did not consider values and preferences. When they were considered, it was often suboptimal. Disregard for values and preferences might have partly contributed to divisive and unpopular COVID-19 policies. Given the possibility of future health emergencies, we recommend guideline developers identify efficient and effective methods for considering values and preferences in crisis situations.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Kirsh S, Ling M, Jassal T, et al. Values and preferences in COVID-19 public health guidelines: a systematic review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 39034014. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111473

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。