将绝经后女性视角纳入骨质疏松症临床指南:一项系统综述
该研究系统检索指南数据库及指南制定机构网站,评估绝经后女性骨质疏松性原发骨折预防临床实践指南对个体视角的纳入情况,共纳入33部指南。结果显示24.2%的指南在制定中明确纳入个体视角,12.1%的指南纳入相关研究证据支持推荐;质量评估中适用性、制定的严谨性和利益相关者参与领域平均得分最低,分别为42.4%、44.7%和45.7%。
要点
- 24.2%的指南在制定中明确纳入个体视角,12.1%纳入相关研究证据支持推荐。
- 质量评估中适用性、制定的严谨性和利益相关者参与领域平均得分最低。
- 质量更高的指南更可能在制定中纳入女性视角(均数差39.31,P=.003)。
核心结论
- 将女性视角纳入骨质疏松症原发骨折预防指南制定过程仍不充分。
- 作者呼吁指南制定者改善这一状况,并提示使用者和政策制定者在应用或实施该领域指南时注意这些局限。
研究设计与样本
- 对指南数据库和临床实践指南制定组织网站进行全面的系统检索。
- 使用AGREE II工具评估指南质量,重点关注患者或代表在制定过程中的纳入情况。
- 共检索到491部符合条件的临床实践指南,最终纳入33部。
主要发现
- 大多数指南由科学学会制定(63.6%),主要来自欧洲(39.4%)和北美(30.3%)。
- 24.2%的指南在制定中明确纳入个体视角,12.1%的指南纳入关于该方面的研究证据以支持其推荐。
- 质量评估中平均得分最低的领域为适用性(42.4%)、制定的严谨性(44.7%)和利益相关者参与(45.7%),根据评估61%的指南被推荐使用。
- 质量更高的指南更可能在制定中纳入女性视角(均数差39.31,P=.003)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To assess the inclusion of individuals' perspectives in the development of osteoporosis Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPGs) for primary fracture prevention in postmenopausal women. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We performed a comprehensive systematic search across guideline databases and (CPGs) developing organizations websites. Using the AGREE II tool, we assessed the quality of the guidelines, with particular emphasis on the inclusion of patients, or representatives in the development process. We also examined if women's perspectives were considered at the recommendations level and explored the potential association between the inclusion of patients' values and preferences with the quality of the CPGs. RESULTS: We retrieved a total of 491 eligible CPGs, of which 33 were finally included. The majority of the CPGs were developed by scientific societies (63.6%), primarily from Europe (39.4%) and North America (30.3%). One in every four (24.2%) guidelines explicitly included individuals' perspectives in their development, and one in ten (12.1%) included research evidence about this aspect to support their recommendations. The domains with the lowest mean scores in the quality assessment were applicability (42.4%), rigor of development (44.7%), and stakeholder involvement (45.7%), and 61% were recommended for use according to our assessment. Guidelines of higher quality were more likely to include women's perspective in their development (mean difference 39.31, P = .003). CONCLUSION: The incorporation of women's perspectives into the process of developing guidelines for primary fracture prevention in osteoporosis remains inadequate. Our findings serve as a call for guideline developers to improve this situation, and for users, and policymakers to be aware of these limitations, when using or implementing guidelines in this field.
引用
- Medina-Aedo M, Günther M, Arauz I, et al. Incorporating postmenopausal women's perspectives into osteoporosis clinical guidelines: a systematic review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 39029540. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111468
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。