意向性治疗与符合方案分析:差异与相似之处
随机试验可采用偏向解释性或偏向实用性的设计。实用性研究接近真实世界条件,评估治疗有效性时考虑方案依从性,意向性治疗(ITT)分析是基础;解释性研究接近最优条件,评估治疗效力,常用符合方案(PP)分析。ITT与PP服务于不同目标,各有局限:PP排除不依从者可能丧失随机化优势并引入随机化后混杂,ITT可能稀释治疗效应。两者均可受选择偏倚影响,g方法(如逆概率加权)可能有助于处理相关偏倚。
要点
- ITT分析比较所有随机化参与者的结局,不考虑实际接受的治疗。
- PP分析仅纳入依从参与者的结局,可能丧失随机化优势并引入随机化后混杂。
- ITT分析可能稀释治疗效应,且依从性水平不同可限制其发现的外推性。
核心结论
- ITT与PP分析各有不同目标,在控制偏倚时均可有效且互补,但各有局限。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为方法学论述,讨论随机试验中ITT与PP分析在构思、设计、实施、分析和解释中的策略。
主要发现
- PP分析排除不依从参与者可丧失随机化优势,导致基线时存在的(影响依从性和结局的)因素出现组间差异。
- 影响依从性的临床和社会因素也可在随机化后的随访期间起作用,因此不完整依从可能引入随机化后混杂。
- ITT分析纳入所有参与者 regardless of adherence,可能稀释治疗效应。
- 不同依从性水平可能限制ITT发现在依从模式多样环境中的适用性。
- ITT和PP分析均可因随访期间差异性失访和无应答(即缺失数据)而受选择偏倚影响。
关键数值与推荐
- 结合高质量全面数据与高级统计方法(称为g方法,如逆概率加权)可能有助于处理PP分析中的随机化后混杂以及ITT和PP分析中的选择偏倚。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Randomized trials can take more explanatory or more pragmatic approaches. Pragmatic studies, conducted closer to real-world conditions, assess treatment effectiveness while considering factors like protocol adherence. In these studies, intention-to-treat (ITT) analysis is fundamental, comparing outcomes regardless of the actual treatment received. Explanatory trials, conducted closer to optimal conditions, evaluate treatment efficacy, commonly with a per protocol (PP) analysis, which includes only outcomes from adherent participants. ITT and PP are strategies used in the conception, design, conduct (protocol execution), analysis, and interpretation of trials. Each serves distinct objectives. While both can be valid, when bias is controlled, and complementary, each has its own limitations. By excluding nonadherent participants, PP analyses can lose the benefits of randomization, resulting in group differences in factors (influencing adherence and outcomes) that were present at baseline. Additionally, clinical and social factors affecting adherence can also operate during follow-up, that is, after randomization. Therefore, incomplete adherence may introduce postrandomization confounding. Conversely, ITT analysis, including all participants regardless of adherence, may dilute treatment effects. Moreover, varying adherence levels could limit the applicability of ITT findings in settings with diverse adherence patterns. Both ITT and PP analyses can be affected by selection bias due to differential losses and nonresponse (ie, missing data) during follow-up. Combining high-quality and comprehensive data with advanced statistical methods, known as g-methods, like inverse probability weighting, may help address postrandomization confounding in PP analysis as well as selection bias in both ITT and PP analyses.
引用
- Molero-Calafell J, Burón A, Castells X, et al. Intention to treat and per protocol analyses: differences and similarities. J Clin Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 38977160. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111457
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。