临床研究中的胁迫性知情同意:一项随机对照试验的研究方案
本研究描述一项前瞻性随机对照试验方案,在女性学院医院招募114例择期前交叉韧带修复患者,随机分为术前评估门诊招募组和手术当日招募组,比较两组对虚构麻醉研究知情同意的自愿性感知,以探讨手术当日知情同意是否构成胁迫。
要点
- 方案拟纳入114例择期前交叉韧带修复患者,随机分为术前评估门诊招募组与手术当日招募组。
- 两组均接受相同常规标准诊疗,术后填写问卷以反映对虚构试验知情同意过程中不当影响的感知。
- 研究结果将为临床试验设计和有关患者决策时间的实践指南提供信息。
核心结论
- 本研究将告知围绕患者应有足够时间做出参与(或不参与)临床研究持久决策的试验设计与实践指南。
- 预期将影响多种临床场景下的试验招募,这些场景中研究者仅有短暂机会与患者接触。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性随机对照试验方案,在女性学院医院招募114例拟行日间前交叉韧带修复(全麻联合收肌管阻滞)的患者。
- 患者被随机分配至术前评估门诊(手术日之前)招募组或手术当日招募组,邀请其同意参加一项关于收肌管阻滞辅助药物的虚构研究。
- 无论分组如何,两组患者均接受相同的常规标准诊疗,并在术后完成问卷以反映对虚构试验知情同意过程中不当影响的感知。
主要发现
- 原文未报告结果。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局为患者对知情同意自愿性的感知,通过术后问卷评估对虚构试验知情同意过程中不当影响的感知。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Despite the low-risk nature of participation in most clinical anesthesia trials, subject recruitment on the same day as surgery is often restricted due to the concerns of researchers and local research ethics boards that same-day consent may not afford adequate time and opportunity for patients to weigh and make decisions, as well as perceptions of patient vulnerability immediately prior to surgery that could impact the voluntary nature and the rigor of the informed consent process. However, specialties such as anesthesiology, critical care, interventional radiology, and emergency medicine have a varied pattern of practice and patient acquaintance that does not typically afford the luxury of time or, in many cases, advance consent for participation in research. Indeed, the initial encounter between anesthesiologists and patients undergoing elective procedures routinely occurs on the day of surgery. Concerns of coercion related to same-day consent for clinical anesthesia research trials have not been borne out in the literature, and represent a significant obstacle to clinical researchers, as well as to the patients who are denied opportunities for potential benefit through participation in research studies. METHODS: We describe the protocol for a prospective randomized controlled trial examining the voluntariness of patient consent, solicited either in advance of surgery or on the same day, to participate in an anesthesia research study at Women's College Hospital. One hundred fourteen patients scheduled to undergo ambulatory anterior cruciate ligament repair facilitated by general anesthesia with an adductor canal block will be randomized for recruitment either (a) in the pre-operative assessment clinic before the day of surgery or (b) on the day of surgery, to be approached for consent to participate in a fabricated research study of adjunct medications in adductor canal blocks. Regardless of allocation, patients in both groups will receive the same routine standard of care and will complete a post-operative questionnaire to signal perceptions of undue influence in the process of providing informed consent for the fabricated trial. DISCUSSION: This study will inform trial design and practice guidelines surrounding the amount of time patients ought to be afforded in order to make durable decisions to participate (or not) in clinical research studies. This is expected to impact trial recruitment in a variety of clinical settings where researchers have only brief opportunities to interface with patients. TRIAL REGISTRATION: The trial was registered prospectively on the Open Science Framework (OSF), registration #46twc, on 2023-Mar-17.
引用
- Brenna CTA, Walton N, Cohn M, et al. Coerced consent in clinical research: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial. Trials. 2024. PMID: 38965542. doi:10.1186/s13063-024-08294-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。