异质性Cox模型中的探索性亚组识别:一种相对简单的程序
针对生存分析,提出一种识别治疗效应较大亚组的新程序「森林搜索」,重点关注治疗可能有害的亚组。该程序筛选所有可能亚组,基于提示伤害的风险比阈值按标准Cox模型评估,并通过反转治疗角色寻找显著获益。模拟显示其性能优于虚拟孪生和广义随机森林,并应用于肿瘤与HIV临床试验公开数据。
要点
- 森林搜索程序筛选所有可能亚组,基于提示伤害的风险比阈值评估。
- 通过反转治疗角色可识别显著获益的亚组。
- 模拟中该方法对虚假异质性控制类型1错误更优,对显著异质性效应有更高功效和分类准确度。
核心结论
- 提出一种相对简单灵活的森林搜索程序,用于识别治疗效应大、尤其可能有害的亚组。
- 模拟中该方法在控制虚假异质性类型1错误、对显著异质性效应的功效和分类准确度方面表现有利。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学论文,提出森林搜索程序并给出类型1错误和功效的数值积分快速近似。
- 描述自助法偏差校正Cox模型估计量,方差用Jackknife近似估计。
- 模拟中与虚拟孪生和广义随机森林比较。
- 应用于肿瘤临床试验和HIV的公开数据集。
主要发现
- 模拟中森林搜索对虚假异质性的类型1错误控制有利,对显著异质性效应有更高功效和分类准确度。
- 与虚拟孪生和广义随机森林比较,森林搜索表现有利。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
For survival analysis applications we propose a novel procedure for identifying subgroups with large treatment effects, with focus on subgroups where treatment is potentially detrimental. The approach, termed forest search, is relatively simple and flexible. All-possible subgroups are screened and selected based on hazard ratio thresholds indicative of harm with assessment according to the standard Cox model. By reversing the role of treatment one can seek to identify substantial benefit. We apply a splitting consistency criteria to identify a subgroup considered "maximally consistent with harm." The type-1 error and power for subgroup identification can be quickly approximated by numerical integration. To aid inference we describe a bootstrap bias-corrected Cox model estimator with variance estimated by a Jacknife approximation. We provide a detailed evaluation of operating characteristics in simulations and compare to virtual twins and generalized random forests where we find the proposal to have favorable performance. In particular, in our simulation setting, we find the proposed approach favorably controls the type-1 error for falsely identifying heterogeneity with higher power and classification accuracy for substantial heterogeneous effects. Two real data applications are provided for publicly available datasets from a clinical trial in oncology, and HIV.
引用
- León LF, Jemielita T, Guo Z, et al. Exploratory subgroup identification in the heterogeneous Cox model: A relatively simple procedure. Stat Med. 2024. PMID: 38951867. doi:10.1002/sim.10163
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。