文献速递流行病学与生物统计

生存结局非随机研究加权分析中的平衡法与建模法:一项模拟研究

Balancing versus modelling in weighted analysis of non-randomised studies with survival outcomes: A simulation study.
PubMed 文献 · Stat Med · 2024-05-27

加权法广泛用于非随机研究的因果效应估计,通常基于倾向性评分(PS)。本研究针对二分类处理与生存结局开展大规模模拟,参数取自系统综述中以PS方法分析医学研究的设定,比较建模法、平衡法与混合法。结果提示平衡法表现劣于预期,但在所考察的平衡方法中熵平衡一致优于方差平衡;估计重叠人群平均处理效应的方法即使PS模型设定错误也表现良好,偏倚很小、标准误较小;标准稳健方差估计量的覆盖度过高,所提出的校正稳健方差估计量在多种情形下改善了覆盖度。

要点

  • 平衡法整体表现劣于预期,熵平衡在所考察的平衡方法中一致优于方差平衡。
  • 估计重叠人群平均处理效应的方法偏倚很小、标准误较小,即使PS模型设定错误亦然。
  • 标准稳健方差估计量的覆盖度过高,所提出的校正稳健方差估计量在多种情形下改善覆盖度。

核心结论

  • 模拟结果显示平衡法方法的表现劣于预期,但在所考察的平衡方法中熵平衡一致优于方差平衡法。
  • 估计重叠人群平均处理效应的方法表现良好,偏倚很小、标准误较小,即使在倾向性评分模型设定错误的情形下亦然。
  • 使用标准稳健方差估计量时所有方法的覆盖度过高,所提出的校正稳健方差估计量在多种情形下改善了覆盖度。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究为一项针对二分类处理与生存结局的大规模模拟研究,比较建模法、平衡法与混合法加权。
  • 模拟参数均在对使用倾向性评分方法分析医学研究的系统综述之后选定,以求最大实际相关性。
  • 研究提出一种新的混合方法,采用协变量平衡倾向性评分与匹配权重的思路,从而避免极端权重。
  • 研究还针对部分方法提出了校正稳健方差估计量。

主要发现

  • 模拟结果显示平衡法方法的表现劣于预期。
  • 在所考察的平衡方法中,熵平衡一致优于方差平衡法。
  • 估计重叠人群平均处理效应的方法偏倚很小、标准误较小,即使倾向性评分模型设定错误亦然。
  • 使用标准稳健方差估计量时,所有方法的覆盖度过高。
  • 所提出的校正稳健方差估计量在多种情形下改善了覆盖度。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Weighting methods are widely used for causal effect estimation in non-randomised studies. In general, these methods use the propensity score (PS), the probability of receiving the treatment given the covariates, to arrive at the respective weights. All of these "modelling" methods actually optimize prediction of the respective outcome, which is, in the PS model, treatment assignment. However, this does not match with the actual aim of weighting, which is eliminating the association between covariates and treatment assignment. In the "balancing" approach, covariates are thus balanced directly by solving systems of numerical equations, explicitly without fitting a PS model. To compare modelling, balancing and hybrid approaches to weighting we performed a large simulation study for a binary treatment and a survival outcome. For maximal practical relevance all simulation parameters were selected after a systematic review of medical studies that used PS methods for analysis. We also introduce a new hybrid method that uses the idea of the covariate balancing propensity score and matching weights, thus avoiding extreme weights. In addition, we present a corrected robust variance estimator for some of the methods. Overall, our simulations results indicate that balancing approach methods work worse than expected. However, among the considered balancing methods, entropy balancing consistently outperforms the variance balancing approach. All methods estimating the average treatment effect in the overlap population perform well with very little bias and small standard errors even in settings with misspecified propensity score models. Finally, the coverage using the standard robust variance estimator was too high for all methods, with the proposed corrected robust variance estimator improving coverage in a variety of settings.

来源:Stat Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Filla T, Schwender H, Kuss O, et al. Balancing versus modelling in weighted analysis of non-randomised studies with survival outcomes: A simulation study. Stat Med. 2024. PMID: 38801062. doi:10.1002/sim.10110

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。