领先同行评审医学期刊中的大多数观察性研究未注册且无公开可获取的研究方案:一项范围综述
该范围综述于2023年3月检索OVID Medline,纳入2022年发表于影响因子前五的综合性医学期刊的观察性研究,随机抽取200篇进行分析。结果显示,200篇观察性研究中仅20篇(10.0%)注册,其中14篇为前瞻性注册;24篇(12.0%)有公开可获取的研究方案。作者认为前瞻性注册率低得令人担忧,应鼓励并标准化观察性研究的前瞻性注册。
要点
- 200篇观察性研究中仅20篇(10.0%)注册,其中14篇为前瞻性注册。
- 24篇(12.0%)观察性研究有公开可获取的研究方案。
- 注册或有方案的研究更多发表于BMJ,且第一作者多在美国以外(英国)工作。
核心结论
- 观察性研究的前瞻性注册率低得令人担忧,应鼓励并标准化观察性研究的前瞻性注册,以确保临床研究的透明度并减少研究浪费。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,2023年3月检索OVID Medline,纳入2022年发表于影响因子前五的综合性医学期刊(The Lancet、BMJ、JAMA、NEJM、Annals of Internal Medicine)的观察性研究(队列研究、病例对照研究、横断面研究或病例系列),检索识别699项研究,290项选为全文,随机抽取200项纳入分析。
主要发现
- 半数研究的第一作者在美国机构工作。
- 大多数研究为队列研究(n=126,63.0%),使用行政医疗记录、电子医疗记录和登记数据库。
- 200项观察性研究中,20项(10.0%)已注册,其中14项为前瞻性注册;24项(12.0%)有公开可获取的研究方案。
- 注册或有方案的研究更多发表于BMJ(n=12/28,42.9%)、第一作者在英国工作(n=10/28,35.7%)并使用电子医疗记录(n=13/28,46.4%),相较无注册且无方案的研究。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为应鼓励并标准化观察性研究的前瞻性注册,以确保临床研究的透明度并减少研究浪费。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Observational studies are not subject to the same requirements as randomized controlled trials, such as registration or publishing a protocol. The aim of this scoping review was to estimate the registration rate of observational studies in leading peer-reviewed medicine journals and to evaluate whether protocols were available in the public domain. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: In March 2023, we searched OVID Medline for observational studies published in 2022 in the top five general medicine journals according to impact factor (The Lancet, The British Medical Journal (BMJ), The Journal of the American Medical Association, The New England Journal of Medicine, and Annals of Internal Medicine). We defined an observational study as a cohort study, a case-control study, a cross-sectional study, or a case series. Information on i) the proportion of observational studies that have been registered and ii) the proportion of observational studies that have a protocol available in the public domain was extracted from a random sample of studies. RESULTS: Our search identified 699 studies; 290 studies were selected as full text, and a random sample of 200 studies was included. For half of the studies, the first author worked at a US institution. Most studies were cohort studies (n = 126, 63.0%) and used administrative healthcare records, electronic healthcare records, and registries. Of the 200 observational studies, 20 (10.0%) were registered. Among those, 14 were prospectively registered. Twenty-four studies (12.0%) had a protocol available in the public domain. Studies that were registered or had a protocol, were more frequently published in the BMJ (n = 12/28, 42.9%), had a first author working in the UK (n = 10/28, 35.7%) and used electronic health care records (n = 13/28, 46.4%) compared to studies with no registration and no protocol. CONCLUSION: The rate of prospectively registered observational studies is worryingly low. Prospective registration of observational studies should be encouraged and standardized to ensure transparency in clinical research and reduce research waste.
引用
- Leducq S, Zaki F, Hollestein LM, et al. The majority of observational studies in leading peer-reviewed medicine journals are not registered and do not have a publicly accessible protocol: a scoping review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 38556099. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111341
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。