医学研究中多分类治疗逆概率治疗加权法的使用与报告:一项系统综述
该系统综述通过检索Pubmed、Embase和Web of Science共筛选5660篇文章,最终纳入来自17个医学领域的106篇文献,分析多分类治疗中逆概率治疗加权(IPTW)的使用频率、实施方式与报告质量。结果显示治疗组数多为3或4组(90篇,84.9%),权重估计最常用多项回归(51篇,48.1%)和广义提升模型(48篇,45.3%);26篇(24.5%)未讨论加权后协变量平衡,仅16篇(15.1%)提及正确推断所需假设。作者认为医学文献中IPTW用于两个以上治疗类别的情况很少,且报告质量欠佳,尤其在假设和模型构建方面。
要点
- 纳入106篇文献中90篇(84.9%)涉及3或4个治疗组,治疗组数范围为3至9组。
- 权重估计最常用多项回归(51篇,48.1%)和广义提升模型(48篇,45.3%)。
- 26篇(24.5%)未讨论加权后协变量平衡,仅16篇(15.1%)提及正确推断所需假设。
核心结论
- 医学文献中IPTW方法很少用于两个以上治疗类别,使用该方法的文献报告质量欠佳,尤其在假设和模型构建方面。
- 作者认为多分类治疗的IPTW可在医学研究中更广泛应用,应用所提出的指南有助于研究者报告结果并确保研究可重复性。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索Pubmed、Embase和Web of Science,筛选5660篇文章,最终纳入来自17个不同医学领域的106篇文章。
- 该系统综述在PROSPERO注册(CRD42022352669)。
主要发现
- 治疗组数在3至9组之间,绝大多数文章(90篇,84.9%)包含3或4组。
- 权重估计最常用的方法为多项回归(51篇,48.1%)和广义提升模型(48篇,45.3%)。
- 91篇文章(85.9%)报告了权重模型的协变量。
- 26篇文章(24.5%)未讨论加权后协变量平衡,仅16篇文章(15.1%)提及获得正确推断所需假设。
关键数值与推荐
- 权重估计方法:多项回归51篇(48.1%),广义提升模型48篇(45.3%)。
- 权重模型协变量报告率:91篇(85.9%)。
- 加权后协变量平衡未讨论:26篇(24.5%);提及正确推断假设:16篇(15.1%)。
- 治疗组数分布:3或4组90篇(84.9%),组数范围3至9组。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Causal inference methods for observational data represent an alternative to randomised controlled trials when they are not feasible or when real-world evidence is sought. Inverse-probability-of-treatment weighting (IPTW) is one of the most popular approaches to account for confounding in observational studies. In medical research, IPTW is mainly applied to estimate the causal effect of a binary treatment, even when the treatment has in fact multiple categories, despite the availability of IPTW estimators for multiple treatment categories. This raises questions about the appropriateness of the use of IPTW in this context. Therefore, we conducted a systematic review of medical publications reporting the use of IPTW in the presence of a multi-category treatment. Our objectives were to investigate the frequency of use and the implementation of these methods in practice, and to assess the quality of their reporting. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Using Pubmed, Embase and Web of Science, we screened 5660 articles and retained 106 articles in the final analysis that were from 17 different medical areas. This systematic review is registered on PROSPERO (CRD42022352669). RESULTS: The number of treatment groups varied between 3 and 9, with a large majority of articles (90 [84.9%]) including 3 or 4 groups. The most commonly used method for estimating the weights was multinomial regression (51 [48.1%]) and generalized boosted models (48 [45.3%]). The covariates of the weight model were reported in 91 articles (85.9 %). Twenty-six articles (24.5 %) did not discuss the balance of covariates after weighting, and only 16 articles (15.1 %) referred to the assumptions needed to obtain correct inferences. CONCLUSION: The results of this systematic review illustrate that medical publications scarcely use IPTW methods for more than two treatment categories. Among the publications that did, the quality of reporting was suboptimal, in particular in regard to the assumptions and model building. IPTW for multi-category treatments could be applied more broadly in medical research, and the application of the proposed guidelines in this context will help researchers to report their results and to ensure reproducibility of their research.
引用
- Bettega F, Mendelson M, Leyrat C, et al. Use and reporting of inverse-probability-of-treatment weighting for multicategory treatments in medical research: a systematic review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 38556101. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111338
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。